To register for this event, please login or create your visitor account.

Tuesday
8 April
2025
10:30 to 12:30
IN PERSON
BY REQUEST
Tuesday 8 April 2025
10:30 to 12:30

Presentation

Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East

The construction sector in the Middle East, with its large-scale and complex projects, is often a fertile ground for disputes. Issues such as delays and extensions of time, frequently linked to inconsistent record-keeping, and disagreements over variations are among the most common. Payment disputes, including delayed payments, retention issues, and non-payment for completed works, are also prevalent, as are conflicts over premature or contested contract terminations. Additionally, the involvement of government and quasi-government entities introduces unique considerations, such as authorisations and certification processes and the complexities of arbitration agreements related to jurisdiction and governing law.

The panel will explore the dispute resolution mechanisms most commonly employed in the region, questioning whether arbitration is truly the preferred approach or whether alternatives like mediation or dispute adjudication boards are gaining prominence. The discussion will also consider the role of expert evidence in resolving technical disputes, evaluating whether it is being used effectively to address issues such as delay analysis and quantum assessments. These insights will shed light on whether the current practices align with the needs of the construction industry.

Another key area of discussion will be the enforcement of arbitral awards in the region. The panel will examine the complexities of enforcing awards involving government or semi-government entities and explore the influence of public policy considerations, including those shaped by Sharia principles, on awards addressing penalties, liquidated damages, or interest.

They will also consider whether local courts are supportive of international awards and how enforcement challenges may vary across jurisdictions.

Join us for this engaging session to gain deeper insights into the evolving landscape of construction arbitration in the Middle East.

Guest Speakers

Raid ABU-MANNEH
Partner
Mayer Brown
Rena SCOTT
Partner & Head of Construction Advisory and Disputes, KSA
Pinsent Masons
Sally KOTB
Partner
Baker McKenzie
Ziad OBEID
Managing Partner
Obeid & Partners

Venue

FTI Consulting
10 rue de Bassano
75116 Paris

Registration for this event is now closed.

 array:25 [
  "__path" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache/c84ebf1432a129894c6a5ed11ec848552cf558ba.php"
  "__data" => array:23 [
    "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419
      #engines: Illuminate\View\Engines\EngineResolver {#2411
        #resolvers: array:3 [
          "file" => Closure() {#2412 …2}
          "php" => Closure() {#2413 …2}
          "blade" => Closure() {#2414 …2}
        ]
        #resolved: array:1 [
          "blade" => Illuminate\View\Engines\CompilerEngine {#4172 …3}
        ]
      }
      #finder: Illuminate\View\FileViewFinder {#2415
        #files: Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
        #paths: array:1 [
          0 => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views"
        ]
        #views: array:19 [
          "single-event" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/single-event.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.section-top" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/section-top.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.section-left" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/section-left.blade.php"
          "partials.event-format" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/event-format.blade.php"
          "partials.event-type" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/event-type.blade.php"
          "partials.entry-sharer" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/entry-sharer.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.section-right" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/section-right.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.medias" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/medias.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.section-bottom" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/section-bottom.blade.php"
          "partials.user-thumbnail" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/user-thumbnail.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.venue" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/venue.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.register" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/register.blade.php"
          "layouts.app-left-right" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/layouts/app-left-right.blade.php"
          "structs.head" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/head.blade.php"
          "structs.header" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/header.blade.php"
          "partials.notices" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/notices.blade.php"
          "partials.breadcrumbs" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/breadcrumbs.blade.php"
          "structs.footer" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/footer.blade.php"
          "partials.nav-social" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/nav-social.blade.php"
        ]
        #hints: []
        #extensions: array:4 [
          0 => "blade.php"
          1 => "php"
          2 => "css"
          3 => "html"
        ]
      }
      #events: Illuminate\Events\Dispatcher {#2417
        #container: Illuminate\Container\Container {#2418
          #resolved: []
          #bindings: []
          #methodBindings: []
          #instances: []
          #scopedInstances: []
          #aliases: []
          #abstractAliases: []
          #extenders: []
          #tags: []
          #buildStack: []
          #with: []
          +contextual: []
          #reboundCallbacks: []
          #globalBeforeResolvingCallbacks: []
          #globalResolvingCallbacks: []
          #globalAfterResolvingCallbacks: []
          #beforeResolvingCallbacks: []
          #resolvingCallbacks: []
          #afterResolvingCallbacks: []
        }
        #listeners: []
        #wildcards: []
        #wildcardsCache: array:38 [
          "creating: single-event" => []
          "composing: single-event" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.section-top" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.section-top" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.section-left" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.section-left" => []
          "creating: partials.event-format" => []
          "composing: partials.event-format" => []
          "creating: partials.event-type" => []
          "composing: partials.event-type" => []
          "creating: partials.entry-sharer" => []
          "composing: partials.entry-sharer" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.section-right" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.section-right" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.medias" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.medias" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.section-bottom" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.section-bottom" => []
          "creating: partials.user-thumbnail" => []
          "composing: partials.user-thumbnail" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.venue" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.venue" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.register" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.register" => []
          "creating: layouts.app-left-right" => []
          "composing: layouts.app-left-right" => []
          "creating: structs.head" => []
          "composing: structs.head" => []
          "creating: structs.header" => []
          "composing: structs.header" => []
          "creating: partials.notices" => []
          "composing: partials.notices" => []
          "creating: partials.breadcrumbs" => []
          "composing: partials.breadcrumbs" => []
          "creating: structs.footer" => []
          "composing: structs.footer" => []
          "creating: partials.nav-social" => []
          "composing: partials.nav-social" => []
        ]
        #queueResolver: null
      }
      #container: Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401
        #resolved: array:7 [
          "view.engine.resolver" => true
          "files" => true
          "config" => true
          "view.finder" => true
          "events" => true
          "view" => true
          "blade.compiler" => true
        ]
        #bindings: array:7 [
          "files" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2403 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "events" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2404 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "config" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2405 …3}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2407 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view.finder" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2408 …2}
            "shared" => false
          ]
          "blade.compiler" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2409 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view.engine.resolver" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2410 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
        ]
        #methodBindings: []
        #instances: array:6 [
          "view.engine.resolver" => Illuminate\View\Engines\EngineResolver {#2411}
          "files" => Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
          "config" => array:2 [
            "view.paths" => array:1 [ …1]
            "view.compiled" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache"
          ]
          "events" => Illuminate\Events\Dispatcher {#2417}
          "view" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
          "blade.compiler" => Illuminate\View\Compilers\BladeCompiler {#2420
            #files: Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
            #cachePath: "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache"
            #extensions: []
            #customDirectives: array:4 [ …4]
            #conditions: []
            #precompilers: []
            #path: null
            #compilers: array:3 [ …3]
            #rawTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #contentTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #escapedTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #echoFormat: "e(%s)"
            #footer: []
            #rawBlocks: []
            #classComponentAliases: array:1 [ …1]
            #classComponentNamespaces: []
            #compilesComponentTags: true
            #firstCaseInSwitch: true
            #echoHandlers: []
            -encodingOptions: 15
            #lastSection: null
            #forElseCounter: 0
          }
        ]
        #scopedInstances: []
        #aliases: []
        #abstractAliases: []
        #extenders: []
        #tags: []
        #buildStack: []
        #with: []
        +contextual: []
        #reboundCallbacks: []
        #globalBeforeResolvingCallbacks: []
        #globalResolvingCallbacks: []
        #globalAfterResolvingCallbacks: []
        #beforeResolvingCallbacks: []
        #resolvingCallbacks: []
        #afterResolvingCallbacks: []
      }
      #shared: array:2 [
        "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
        "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
      ]
      #extensions: array:4 [
        "blade.php" => "blade"
        "php" => "php"
        "css" => "file"
        "html" => "file"
      ]
      #composers: []
      #renderCount: 3
      #renderedOnce: []
      #componentStack: []
      #componentData: []
      #currentComponentData: []
      #slots: []
      #slotStack: []
      #sections: array:4 [
        "content-top" => """
              <div class="wrapper">\n
              <div class="event-status ">\n
                  <div class="event-status_ctn">\n
                                                          <p>To register for this event, please login or create your visitor account.</p>\n
                              <a class="button signin-event is-style-primary-white" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/sign-in/">\n
                                  <span>\n
                                      Sign in\n
                                      <i class="paw-icon-arrow"></i>\n
                                  </span>\n
                              </a>\n
                                              </div>\n
              </div>\n
          </div>
          """
        "content-left" => """
              <div class="event-details is-hidden-touch">\n
              \n
              <div class="event-date">\n
                  <div>Tuesday</div>\n
                  <div>8 April</div>\n
                  <div>2025</div>\n
              </div>\n
              \n
              \n
              <div class="event-time">10:30 to 12:30</div>\n
          \n
              \n
              <div class="event-format">\n
              <div class="term">\n
                  <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="15.036" height="7.786" viewBox="0 0 15.036 7.786">\r\n
            <path d="M7.708,7.328a.269.269,0,0,1,0,.38L.459,14.957A.269.269,0,0,1,0,14.767V.269A.269.269,0,0,1,.459.079Z" transform="translate(15.036) rotate(90)" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
          </svg>\r\n
          \n
                  IN PERSON\n
              </div>\n
          </div>\n
              \n
              \n
              <div class="event-type">\n
              <div class="term">\n
                  BY REQUEST\n
              </div>\n
          </div>\n
                  \n
              \n
              \n
                      <div class="partner-contact" style="margin-top: 20px">\n
                      <button id="gf_button_get_form_6ac8dd6e2322a" class="contact button">Contact the Organiser</button><script>\n
                      (function () {\n
                          var initAjaxButton = function() {\n
                              jQuery('#gf_button_get_form_6ac8dd6e2322a').click(function(){\n
                                  var button = jQuery(this);\n
                                  let modal = $('.modal.global');\n
                                  let modalCtn = modal.find('.modal-content');\n
                                  \n
                                  jQuery.get('https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=show_contact_partner_form&form_id=18&partner_id=4368',function(response){\n
                                      modalCtn.empty();\n
                                      modalCtn.append(response);\n
                                      modal.addClass('is-active');\n
                                      modal.trigger('classChange');\n
                                      if(window['gformInitDatepicker']) {gformInitDatepicker();}\n
                                      /*\n
                                      if('show_contact_partner_form' === 'add_rsvp') {\n
                                          $('.gform_heading').append('<h2>Send a RSVP invitation</h2>');\n
                                      } else if('show_contact_partner_form' === 'add_visitor') {\n
                                          $('.gform_heading').append('<h2>Add an Attendee</h2>');\n
                                      }\n
                                      */\n
                                  });\n
                              });\n
                          };\n
                          window.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', initAjaxButton);\n
                      }());\n
                  </script>\n
                  </div>\n
                  \n
              \n
              <div class="entry-sharer ">\n
              <div class="share-container">\n
                <button\n
                  aria-label="Partager"\n
                  class="share-button"\n
                  data-title="Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East"\n
                  data-excerpt="Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East The construction sector in the [&hellip;]"\n
                  data-url="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/challenges-of-construction-arbitration-in-the-middle-east/"\n
                  >\n
                      <span>Share\n
                          <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="16.32" height="18.157" viewBox="0 0 16.32 18.157">\r\n
            <g>\r\n
              <path d="M13.072,11.714a3.13,3.13,0,0,0-2.423,1.118L6.123,10.489a3.137,3.137,0,0,0,.319-1.411,3.535,3.535,0,0,0-.319-1.411l4.526-2.343a3.171,3.171,0,0,0,2.423,1.118,3.221,3.221,0,1,0,0-6.443A3.278,3.278,0,0,0,9.85,3.275a3.389,3.389,0,0,0,.213,1.171L5.458,6.815a3.179,3.179,0,0,0-2.263-.932,3.221,3.221,0,0,0,.027,6.443,3.179,3.179,0,0,0,2.263-.932l4.606,2.369a3.389,3.389,0,0,0-.213,1.171,3.221,3.221,0,1,0,3.195-3.221m0-10.569a2.156,2.156,0,1,1-2.156,2.13,2.142,2.142,0,0,1,2.156-2.13M3.221,11.261A2.156,2.156,0,1,1,5.378,9.1a2.182,2.182,0,0,1-2.156,2.156m9.85,5.8a2.156,2.156,0,1,1,2.156-2.156,2.164,2.164,0,0,1-2.156,2.156" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
            </g>\r\n
          </svg>\r\n
                      </span>\n
                </button>\n
              </div>\n
          \n
                      <div class="favorite-container">\n
                      <button class="fav "\n
                          data-nonce="6a03838bfb" data-id="39667"\n
                          aria-label="Add to favorite"\n
                          title="Add to my favourites">\n
                          <span class="star">\n
                              <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" viewBox="0 0 30 30">\n
            <g>\n
              <path class="fav-outline" fill-rule="evenodd" fill="currentColor" d="M15.84,7.4l1.94,4.76,5.13.38c.35.03.61.33.59.68-.01.17-.09.33-.22.44l-3.92,3.32,1.22,4.99c.03.12.02.25-.02.37h0c-.12.33-.49.5-.82.38-.04-.01-.08-.03-.12-.06l-4.37-2.71-4.37,2.71c-.3.18-.69.09-.88-.21-.02-.04-.04-.08-.06-.12h0c-.04-.12-.05-.25-.02-.37l1.22-4.99-3.93-3.32c-.27-.23-.3-.63-.07-.9.11-.13.27-.21.44-.22l5.13-.38,1.94-4.75c.13-.33.5-.48.83-.35.16.06.29.19.35.35ZM17.1,12.71l-1.85-4.53-1.95,4.78-5.14.38,3.94,3.33-1.23,5.01,4.38-2.72,4.38,2.72-1.23-5.01,3.93-3.33-5.14-.38-.1-.24Z"/>\n
              <path class="fav-filled" fill="currentColor" d="M15.84,7.4l1.94,4.76,5.13.38c.35.03.61.33.59.68-.01.17-.09.33-.22.44l-3.92,3.32,1.22,4.99c.03.12.02.25-.02.37h0c-.12.33-.49.5-.82.38-.04-.01-.08-.03-.12-.06l-4.37-2.71-4.37,2.71c-.3.18-.69.09-.88-.21-.02-.04-.04-.08-.06-.12h0c-.04-.12-.05-.25-.02-.37l1.22-4.99-3.93-3.32c-.27-.23-.3-.63-.07-.9.11-.13.27-.21.44-.22l5.13-.38,1.94-4.75c.13-.33.5-.48.83-.35.16.06.29.19.35.35Z"/>\n
            </g>\n
          </svg>                </span>\n
                      </button>\n
                  </div>\n
              </div></div>
          """
        "content-right" => """
              <div class="page-header">\n
              <div class="event-category">\n
                  [Academic]\n
              </div>\n
              <h1>Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East</h1>\n
              <div class="event-terms">\n
                              <a class="theme" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/theme/construction/">\n
                          #Construction\n
                      </a>\n
                                      <a class="region" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/region/world/">\n
                          #World\n
                      </a>\n
                      </div>\n
          </div>\n
          \n
          <div class="event-details is-hidden-desktop">\n
              <div class="event-date">Tuesday 8 April 2025</div>\n
              \n
              \n
                      \n
                  <div></div>\n
              \n
              \n
              <div class="event-time">10:30 to 12:30</div>\n
              \n
              \n
              <div class="entry-sharer ">\n
              <div class="share-container">\n
                <button\n
                  aria-label="Partager"\n
                  class="share-button"\n
                  data-title="Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East"\n
                  data-excerpt="Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East The construction sector in the [&hellip;]"\n
                  data-url="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/challenges-of-construction-arbitration-in-the-middle-east/"\n
                  >\n
                      <span>Share\n
                          <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="16.32" height="18.157" viewBox="0 0 16.32 18.157">\r\n
            <g>\r\n
              <path d="M13.072,11.714a3.13,3.13,0,0,0-2.423,1.118L6.123,10.489a3.137,3.137,0,0,0,.319-1.411,3.535,3.535,0,0,0-.319-1.411l4.526-2.343a3.171,3.171,0,0,0,2.423,1.118,3.221,3.221,0,1,0,0-6.443A3.278,3.278,0,0,0,9.85,3.275a3.389,3.389,0,0,0,.213,1.171L5.458,6.815a3.179,3.179,0,0,0-2.263-.932,3.221,3.221,0,0,0,.027,6.443,3.179,3.179,0,0,0,2.263-.932l4.606,2.369a3.389,3.389,0,0,0-.213,1.171,3.221,3.221,0,1,0,3.195-3.221m0-10.569a2.156,2.156,0,1,1-2.156,2.13,2.142,2.142,0,0,1,2.156-2.13M3.221,11.261A2.156,2.156,0,1,1,5.378,9.1a2.182,2.182,0,0,1-2.156,2.156m9.85,5.8a2.156,2.156,0,1,1,2.156-2.156,2.164,2.164,0,0,1-2.156,2.156" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
            </g>\r\n
          </svg>\r\n
                      </span>\n
                </button>\n
              </div>\n
          \n
                      <div class="favorite-container">\n
                      <button class="fav "\n
                          data-nonce="6a03838bfb" data-id="39667"\n
                          aria-label="Add to favorite"\n
                          title="Add to my favourites">\n
                          <span class="star">\n
                              <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" viewBox="0 0 30 30">\n
            <g>\n
              <path class="fav-outline" fill-rule="evenodd" fill="currentColor" d="M15.84,7.4l1.94,4.76,5.13.38c.35.03.61.33.59.68-.01.17-.09.33-.22.44l-3.92,3.32,1.22,4.99c.03.12.02.25-.02.37h0c-.12.33-.49.5-.82.38-.04-.01-.08-.03-.12-.06l-4.37-2.71-4.37,2.71c-.3.18-.69.09-.88-.21-.02-.04-.04-.08-.06-.12h0c-.04-.12-.05-.25-.02-.37l1.22-4.99-3.93-3.32c-.27-.23-.3-.63-.07-.9.11-.13.27-.21.44-.22l5.13-.38,1.94-4.75c.13-.33.5-.48.83-.35.16.06.29.19.35.35ZM17.1,12.71l-1.85-4.53-1.95,4.78-5.14.38,3.94,3.33-1.23,5.01,4.38-2.72,4.38,2.72-1.23-5.01,3.93-3.33-5.14-.38-.1-.24Z"/>\n
              <path class="fav-filled" fill="currentColor" d="M15.84,7.4l1.94,4.76,5.13.38c.35.03.61.33.59.68-.01.17-.09.33-.22.44l-3.92,3.32,1.22,4.99c.03.12.02.25-.02.37h0c-.12.33-.49.5-.82.38-.04-.01-.08-.03-.12-.06l-4.37-2.71-4.37,2.71c-.3.18-.69.09-.88-.21-.02-.04-.04-.08-.06-.12h0c-.04-.12-.05-.25-.02-.37l1.22-4.99-3.93-3.32c-.27-.23-.3-.63-.07-.9.11-.13.27-.21.44-.22l5.13-.38,1.94-4.75c.13-.33.5-.48.83-.35.16.06.29.19.35.35Z"/>\n
            </g>\n
          </svg>                </span>\n
                      </button>\n
                  </div>\n
              </div></div>\n
          \n
          <div class="partner-company">\n
                                      <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/partner/fti-consulting/">\n
                          <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/5-8c91b4cf34801a0f50f49fc1e3b236a3/2023/01/.fti_logo_blue_jpg.jpg" alt="Logo partner">\n
                      </a>\n
                      \n
              </div>\n
          \n
              \n
                      <div class="event-presentation event-section box">\n
                      <h3 class="mt-0 is-style-h2">Presentation</h3>\n
                      <p>Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East </p>\n
          <p>The construction sector in the Middle East, with its large-scale and complex projects, is often a fertile ground for disputes. Issues such as delays and extensions of time, frequently linked to inconsistent record-keeping, and disagreements over variations are among the most common. Payment disputes, including delayed payments, retention issues, and non-payment for completed works, are also prevalent, as are conflicts over premature or contested contract terminations. Additionally, the involvement of government and quasi-government entities introduces unique considerations, such as authorisations and certification processes and the complexities of arbitration agreements related to jurisdiction and governing law. </p>\n
          <p>The panel will explore the dispute resolution mechanisms most commonly employed in the region, questioning whether arbitration is truly the preferred approach or whether alternatives like mediation or dispute adjudication boards are gaining prominence. The discussion will also consider the role of expert evidence in resolving technical disputes, evaluating whether it is being used effectively to address issues such as delay analysis and quantum assessments. These insights will shed light on whether the current practices align with the needs of the construction industry. </p>\n
          <p>Another key area of discussion will be the enforcement of arbitral awards in the region. The panel will examine the complexities of enforcing awards involving government or semi-government entities and explore the influence of public policy considerations, including those shaped by Sharia principles, on awards addressing penalties, liquidated damages, or interest.</p>\n
          <p>They will also consider whether local courts are supportive of international awards and how enforcement challenges may vary across jurisdictions. </p>\n
          <p>Join us for this engaging session to gain deeper insights into the evolving landscape of construction arbitration in the Middle East.</p>\n
          \n
                  </div>\n
              
          """
        "content-bottom" => """
                  <div class="event_speakers_hld event-section">\n
                  <h3 class="is-style-h2">Guest Speakers</h3>\n
                  <div class="event-speakers">\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/raid-abu-manneh-10293/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/rabu.png" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Raid ABU-MANNEH</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Partner</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Mayer Brown</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/rena-scott-10294/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/rena-scottpinsentmasons-com_.png" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Rena SCOTT</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Partner &amp; Head of Construction Advisory and Disputes, KSA</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Pinsent Masons</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/sally-kotb-10295/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/sally.png" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Sally KOTB</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Partner</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Baker McKenzie</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/ziadobeidpartners-com/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/me--ziad-obeid-photo.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Ziad OBEID</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Managing Partner</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Obeid &amp; Partners</div>\n
              </div>\n
                              </div>\n
              </div>\n
          \n
          \n
          \n
          \n
              <div class="register-in_person event-venue event-section">\n
              <div class="event_address">\n
                  <h3 class="is-style-h2">Venue</h3>\n
                  <b>FTI Consulting</b><br>\n
                  10 rue de Bassano<br>\n
                  75116 Paris\n
                      </div>\n
              <div class="event_map">\n
                  <div class="maps"></div>\n
                  <iframe\n
                      width="520"\n
                      height="320"\n
                      frameborder="0" style="border:0"\n
                      referrerpolicy="no-referrer-when-downgrade"\n
                      src="https://www.google.com/maps/embed/v1/place?key=AIzaSyCykTSHbAIskoaDWw4hqClIH18XDau4D7k&q=10+rue+de+Bassano,75116,Paris"\n
                      allowfullscreen\n
                      data-lenis-prevent\n
                      >\n
                  </iframe>\n
              </div>\n
          </div>\n
          \n
          <div id="register" class="event-registration event-section">\n
              <div>\n
                  \n
                  \n
                  <div class="event-register aligncompact">\n
                      <p class="has-text-align-center"><strong>\n
                      Registration for this event is now closed.\n
                  </strong></p>\n
              </div>    </div>\n
          </div>    
          """
      ]
      #sectionStack: []
      #loopsStack: []
      #pushes: []
      #prepends: []
      #pushStack: []
      #translationReplacements: []
    }
    "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
    "override" => "app"
    "display_sidebar" => false
    "notices" => []
    "browser" => null
    "displayArchiveStructs" => true
    "relatedEdition" => WP_Post {#4176
      +ID: 39376
      +post_author: "234"
      +post_date: "2024-11-05 09:20:47"
      +post_date_gmt: "2024-11-05 09:20:47"
      +post_content: """
        <!-- wp:group {"layout":{"type":"constrained"}} -->\n
        <div class="wp-block-group"><!-- wp:group {"layout":{"type":"constrained"}} -->\n
        <div class="wp-block-group"><!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>PAW 2025 was the 9th edition of the Paris Arbitration Week and by far the most successful edition to date, breaking all previous records and confirming PAW's position as the essential milestone for the global arbitration community.</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>The 2025 edition enjoyed the extraordinary support of 253 partners from around the world and featured an unprecedented 230 events in five days, with 145 held in person and 37 in hybrid format, alongside over 40 social events and cocktail receptions! The events showcased a wealth of fascinating topics on international arbitration with world-class speakers, and attracted a record number of participants from around the globe, with over 40,500 registration requests during the week!</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>In line with its commitments, PAW 2025 featured Professor Mohamed Abdel Wahab's keynote speech on diversity and the PAW Sustainability Event, introduced by Mr. Fabius' keynote speech, which focused on sustainable development-related fundamental rights in arbitration.</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>2025 also marked a significant milestone with the week seeing more than 6,000 unique active accounts on the PAW website, almost doubling last year's figures and demonstrating the growing global reach and engagement of the event.<br></p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>As co-Presidents of PAW 2025, we could not be prouder of what the PAW Board achieved in 2025!</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p><strong>Diamana Diawara &amp; Benjamin Siino</strong></p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph --></div>\n
        <!-- /wp:group --></div>\n
        <!-- /wp:group -->
        """
      +post_title: "2025"
      +post_excerpt: ""
      +post_status: "publish"
      +comment_status: "closed"
      +ping_status: "closed"
      +post_password: ""
      +post_name: "2025"
      +to_ping: ""
      +pinged: ""
      +post_modified: "2026-03-18 17:51:59"
      +post_modified_gmt: "2026-03-18 17:51:59"
      +post_content_filtered: ""
      +post_parent: 0
      +guid: "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/?post_type=edition&#038;p=39376"
      +menu_order: 0
      +post_type: "edition"
      +post_mime_type: ""
      +comment_count: "0"
      +filter: "raw"
      +"isCurrent": ""
      +"num": "2025"
      +"dateOpeningRegister": "2025-01-07"
      +"datePawEventRegister": ""
      +"dateStart": "2025-04-07"
      +"dateEnd": "2025-04-11"
      +"committeeImage": "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/paw-board-2025-_1-2-e1763459987643.jpg"
      +"committeeDescription": "<p><strong>From left to right :</strong> Elsa PAPAREMBORDE (Vice-President), Alexandra VAN DER MEULEN (Treasurer), Anastasia DAVIS BONDARENKO (Vice-President), Niels AUJOUANNET-KELNER (Vice-President), Benjamin SIINO (Co-President), Claire PAULY (Co-Secretary General), Diamana DIAWARA (Co-President), Catherine SCHROEDER (Vice-President), Astrid WESTPHALEN (Vice-President), Vanessa THIEFFRY (Co-Secretary General), Alexandre VAGENHEIM (Vice-President).</p>"
      +"emailHeader": "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/header-brevo-paw-2025-1.jpg"
      +"stats": {#4175
        +"eventsCount": "238"
        +"partnersCount": "256"
        +"participantsCount": "6400"
        +"registrationsCount": "32000"
        +"satisfaction": ""
      }
    }
    "edition_dates" => "23 - 27 March 2026"
    "static_pages" => array:9 [
      "middle_office" => "89"
      "digital_library" => "13219"
      "legal_notice" => "955"
      "privacy_statement" => "12766"
      "contact_us" => "95"
      "sign_in" => "424"
      "visitor_register" => "40592"
      "partner_register" => "28"
      "maintenance" => "40491"
    ]
    "event" => WP_Post {#4181
      +ID: 39667
      +post_author: "10188"
      +post_date: "2025-04-03 14:31:39"
      +post_date_gmt: "2025-04-03 14:31:39"
      +post_content: """
        Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East \r\n
        \r\n
        \r\n
        The construction sector in the Middle East, with its large-scale and complex projects, is often a fertile ground for disputes. Issues such as delays and extensions of time, frequently linked to inconsistent record-keeping, and disagreements over variations are among the most common. Payment disputes, including delayed payments, retention issues, and non-payment for completed works, are also prevalent, as are conflicts over premature or contested contract terminations. Additionally, the involvement of government and quasi-government entities introduces unique considerations, such as authorisations and certification processes and the complexities of arbitration agreements related to jurisdiction and governing law. \r\n
        \r\n
        The panel will explore the dispute resolution mechanisms most commonly employed in the region, questioning whether arbitration is truly the preferred approach or whether alternatives like mediation or dispute adjudication boards are gaining prominence. The discussion will also consider the role of expert evidence in resolving technical disputes, evaluating whether it is being used effectively to address issues such as delay analysis and quantum assessments. These insights will shed light on whether the current practices align with the needs of the construction industry. \r\n
        \r\n
        Another key area of discussion will be the enforcement of arbitral awards in the region. The panel will examine the complexities of enforcing awards involving government or semi-government entities and explore the influence of public policy considerations, including those shaped by Sharia principles, on awards addressing penalties, liquidated damages, or interest.\r\n
        \r\n
        They will also consider whether local courts are supportive of international awards and how enforcement challenges may vary across jurisdictions. \r\n
        \r\n
        Join us for this engaging session to gain deeper insights into the evolving landscape of construction arbitration in the Middle East.
        """
      +post_title: "Challenges of construction arbitration in the Middle East"
      +post_excerpt: ""
      +post_status: "publish"
      +comment_status: "closed"
      +ping_status: "closed"
      +post_password: ""
      +post_name: "challenges-of-construction-arbitration-in-the-middle-east"
      +to_ping: ""
      +pinged: ""
      +post_modified: "2025-04-03 14:31:39"
      +post_modified_gmt: "2025-04-03 14:31:39"
      +post_content_filtered: ""
      +post_parent: 0
      +guid: "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/challenges-of-construction-arbitration-in-the-middle-east/"
      +menu_order: 0
      +post_type: "event"
      +post_mime_type: ""
      +comment_count: "0"
      +filter: "raw"
      +"review": ""
      +"state": "published"
      +"themes": array:1 [
        0 => WP_Term {#4180
          +term_id: 8
          +name: "Construction"
          +slug: "construction"
          +term_group: 0
          +term_taxonomy_id: 8
          +taxonomy: "theme"
          +description: ""
          +parent: 0
          +count: 72
          +filter: "raw"
        }
      ]
      +"themeIDs": array:1 [
        0 => 8
      ]
      +"regions": array:1 [
        0 => WP_Term {#4179
          +term_id: 65
          +name: "World"
          +slug: "world"
          +term_group: 0
          +term_taxonomy_id: 65
          +taxonomy: "region"
          +description: ""
          +parent: 0
          +count: 372
          +filter: "raw"
        }
      ]
      +"regionIDs": array:1 [
        0 => 65
      ]
      +"partnerID": "4368"
      +"type": "by_request"
      +"category": "academic"
      +"format": "in_person"
      +"paw_networking": "on"
      +"coHosts": []
      +"date": "2025-04-08"
      +"startingTimeSlot": "45000"
      +"startTime": "10:30"
      +"endTime": "12:30"
      +"dateOpeningRegister": "2025-01-07"
      +"dateLimitRegister": "2025-04-02"
      +"showDateOpeningRegister": false
      +"isOpenForRegistration": true
      +"typeStart": "morning"
      +"edition": "39376"
      +"isCurrent": false
      +"registrationType": "paw"
      +"externalRegistrationLink": ""
      +"ticketsNumber": "206"
      +"onlineConfLink": ""
      +"hasWaitingList": false
      +"replay": ""
      +"photos": ""
      +"publication": ""
      +"publication_description": ""
      +"address": {#4178
        +"street": "10 rue de Bassano"
        +"building": "FTI Consulting"
        +"city": "Paris"
        +"postcode": "75116"
        +"information": ""
        +"gps": "48.8683488,2.2969428"
        +"maps_query": "10+rue+de+Bassano,75116,Paris"
      }
      +"speakerHosts": []
      +"speakerGuests": array:4 [
        0 => "10293"
        1 => "10294"
        2 => "10295"
        3 => "2575"
      ]
      +"attendeeReminderLastSent": ""
      +"attendees": array:392 [
        10082 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10082
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736226252
          "date_scan" => 1744099579
        ]
        9978 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 9978
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736239118
          "date_scan" => 1744100545
        ]
        10059 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10059
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736249242
        ]
        6828 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6828
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736258160
        ]
        10115 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10115
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736266844
        ]
        10074 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10074
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736273209
        ]
        9993 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9993
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736303181
        ]
        10133 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10133
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740570681
        ]
        10130 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10130
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736342472
          "date_scan" => 1744101114
        ]
        10138 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10138
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736346233
        ]
        7029 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 7029
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736418925
          "date_scan" => 1744101297
        ]
        7688 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7688
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736430027
        ]
        2505 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2505
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736437188
        ]
        10122 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10122
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736484096
        ]
        10159 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10159
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742108559
        ]
        1813 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1813
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736585092
        ]
        9447 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9447
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736607799
        ]
        10095 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10095
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
        ]
        10185 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10185
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736785734
        ]
        10077 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10077
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736775202
        ]
        5950 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5950
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736779751
        ]
        5772 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5772
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736780892
        ]
        10211 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10211
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736797398
        ]
        10215 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10215
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736851278
        ]
        10217 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10217
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736854594
        ]
        10218 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10218
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736856963
        ]
        602 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 602
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736857395
        ]
        6344 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6344
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736860925
        ]
        2171 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2171
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736868172
        ]
        10226 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10226
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736885542
        ]
        6180 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6180
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736915663
        ]
        1581 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 1581
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1743577095
          "date_scan" => 1744103199
        ]
        10181 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10181
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736945231
        ]
        985 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 985
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1736947653
        ]
        7231 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7231
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737043501
        ]
        4404 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 4404
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737120952
        ]
        10269 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10269
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737133862
        ]
        10273 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10273
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737190451
        ]
        6111 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6111
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737202877
        ]
        10276 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10276
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737302590
        ]
        1347 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1347
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737346877
        ]
        6792 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6792
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737371480
        ]
        2661 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2661
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737374808
        ]
        1401 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 1401
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737387869
          "date_scan" => 1744102567
        ]
        1043 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1043
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737390020
        ]
        3896 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3896
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742405113
        ]
        9979 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 9979
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737464622
          "date_scan" => 1744100525
        ]
        313 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 313
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737546972
        ]
        10364 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10364
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737639515
        ]
        2273 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 2273
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737641515
          "date_scan" => 1744100250
        ]
        2687 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2687
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737651920
        ]
        10062 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10062
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737652348
        ]
        762 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 762
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737719134
        ]
        10393 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10393
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737906504
        ]
        10394 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10394
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737910289
        ]
        10370 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10370
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737925391
        ]
        10397 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10397
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737933175
        ]
        10398 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10398
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1737934448
        ]
        10120 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10120
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738054397
        ]
        10408 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10408
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738056676
        ]
        1884 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1884
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738066745
        ]
        5997 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5997
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738081975
        ]
        10132 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10132
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738106415
        ]
        10270 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10270
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742419411
        ]
        1195 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1195
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738160597
        ]
        1474 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1474
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738162243
        ]
        10442 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10442
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1743774105
          "date_scan" => 1744100333
        ]
        1677 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1677
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738164697
        ]
        1749 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1749
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742293893
        ]
        10461 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10461
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738203386
        ]
        6911 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 6911
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738243998
          "date_scan" => 1744106728
        ]
        2313 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 2313
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738246793
          "date_scan" => 1744101056
        ]
        6870 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6870
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738250797
        ]
        8059 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8059
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738252965
        ]
        10489 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10489
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738261493
        ]
        10490 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10490
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738273065
        ]
        6212 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6212
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738314843
        ]
        8032 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8032
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738503881
        ]
        5096 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5096
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741324995
        ]
        10608 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10608
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738586717
        ]
        10566 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10566
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738592026
        ]
        10621 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10621
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738597231
        ]
        7602 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7602
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738608259
        ]
        10636 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10636
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738618771
          "date_scan" => 1744105498
        ]
        10198 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10198
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738651942
        ]
        1255 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1255
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738662270
        ]
        2434 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2434
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738666491
        ]
        10652 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10652
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738667478
          "date_scan" => 1744099500
        ]
        1788 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 1788
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1743516412
          "date_scan" => 1744100625
        ]
        1250 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1250
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738683125
        ]
        10668 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10668
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738685935
        ]
        10296 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10296
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738686049
          "date_scan" => 1744101047
        ]
        10575 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10575
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738694324
        ]
        10694 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10694
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738759577
        ]
        6350 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6350
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738764695
        ]
        5178 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5178
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738771603
        ]
        7277 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 7277
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738834692
          "date_scan" => 1744102158
        ]
        10722 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10722
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738840342
        ]
        653 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 653
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738852063
        ]
        6862 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6862
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738860578
        ]
        2740 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2740
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738860965
        ]
        10757 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10757
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739252889
        ]
        10395 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10395
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738921257
        ]
        3449 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3449
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738925226
        ]
        10776 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10776
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738939482
        ]
        1207 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1207
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738942931
        ]
        10785 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10785
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1738987187
        ]
        10794 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10794
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1744106713
          "date_scan" => 1744100491
        ]
        6269 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6269
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739177498
        ]
        10822 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10822
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739188708
        ]
        2421 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2421
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739191878
        ]
        10832 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10832
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739195773
        ]
        6248 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6248
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739197221
        ]
        10615 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10615
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739201716
        ]
        9742 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9742
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739212259
        ]
        10856 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10856
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739240211
        ]
        7690 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7690
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
        ]
        10892 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10892
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739288513
        ]
        10713 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10713
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739301375
          "date_scan" => 1744106598
        ]
        10906 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10906
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739314591
        ]
        6631 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6631
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739355468
        ]
        10921 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10921
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739358257
        ]
        6779 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6779
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739363599
        ]
        10850 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10850
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739365981
          "date_scan" => 1744104753
        ]
        10535 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10535
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739366666
        ]
        5877 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5877
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739370071
        ]
        5466 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5466
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739370096
        ]
        3380 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3380
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739376683
        ]
        10760 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10760
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739409627
        ]
        6802 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6802
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739443627
        ]
        7881 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7881
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739443689
        ]
        7701 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7701
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739444777
        ]
        409 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 409
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739468170
        ]
        10775 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10775
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739477240
        ]
        10987 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10987
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739491312
        ]
        449 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 449
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739498817
          "date_scan" => 1744100719
        ]
        11000 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 11000
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739527446
          "date_scan" => 1744101692
        ]
        3120 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3120
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739540174
        ]
        1342 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1342
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739544562
        ]
        2552 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2552
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739553730
        ]
        7283 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7283
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739615540
        ]
        7771 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7771
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739621888
        ]
        10985 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10985
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
        ]
        8088 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8088
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739694351
        ]
        11060 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11060
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739710009
        ]
        11061 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 11061
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739712578
          "date_scan" => 1744100120
        ]
        11066 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11066
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739724126
        ]
        11067 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11067
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739726246
        ]
        1438 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1438
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739727270
        ]
        9278 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 9278
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739731163
          "date_scan" => 1744106676
        ]
        11082 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11082
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739794517
        ]
        11087 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11087
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739798987
        ]
        11106 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11106
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739808858
        ]
        11109 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11109
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739809388
        ]
        10047 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10047
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739874014
        ]
        941 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 941
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739877834
        ]
        2611 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2611
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739879065
        ]
        9917 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9917
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739879428
        ]
        3663 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3663
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739880803
        ]
        654 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 654
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739881299
          "date_scan" => 1744100597
        ]
        6273 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6273
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739881446
        ]
        3666 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3666
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739884368
        ]
        11143 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 11143
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739888051
          "date_scan" => 1744100581
        ]
        3766 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 3766
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739891705
          "date_scan" => 1744099641
        ]
        6233 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6233
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739893802
        ]
        8848 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8848
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739896157
        ]
        11163 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11163
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739904734
        ]
        11166 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11166
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739924646
        ]
        6069 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6069
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739952112
        ]
        8472 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8472
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739955995
        ]
        1328 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1328
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739962836
        ]
        10486 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10486
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739978482
        ]
        11215 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11215
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1739995887
        ]
        9942 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9942
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740006475
        ]
        10479 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10479
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740026018
        ]
        9002 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 9002
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740045998
          "date_scan" => 1744100610
        ]
        11246 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11246
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740051164
        ]
        11114 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11114
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740058869
        ]
        11257 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11257
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740059360
        ]
        8346 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8346
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740130964
        ]
        10469 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10469
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740145604
        ]
        10751 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10751
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740145721
        ]
        10246 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10246
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740145911
          "date_scan" => 1744101348
        ]
        1844 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1844
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740571110
        ]
        11316 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11316
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740152074
        ]
        8245 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8245
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740153234
        ]
        5947 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5947
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740160283
        ]
        11318 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 11318
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740165948
          "date_scan" => 1744100982
        ]
        3054 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 3054
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740230253
          "date_scan" => 1744106038
        ]
        11341 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11341
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740239119
        ]
        9045 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9045
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740306959
        ]
        11020 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11020
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740324535
        ]
        4485 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 4485
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1744019897
        ]
        871 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 871
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740374237
        ]
        11359 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11359
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740384082
        ]
        3460 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3460
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740407018
        ]
        9981 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9981
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740407312
        ]
        3426 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3426
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740414100
        ]
        11247 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11247
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740429212
        ]
        3057 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3057
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740477085
        ]
        1571 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1571
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740480623
        ]
        3435 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 3435
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740484426
          "date_scan" => 1744103126
        ]
        7758 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7758
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740487037
        ]
        500 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 500
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740503444
        ]
        10900 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10900
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740569884
        ]
        6658 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6658
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740581922
        ]
        2706 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2706
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740648403
        ]
        7367 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7367
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740660768
        ]
        6071 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6071
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740675292
        ]
        11573 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11573
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740677412
        ]
        11666 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11666
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740933303
        ]
        11669 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11669
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740949749
        ]
        6366 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6366
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740953722
        ]
        11615 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11615
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740957017
        ]
        1994 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1994
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740990609
        ]
        10430 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10430
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1740999164
        ]
        724 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 724
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1744095240
          "date_scan" => 1744100914
        ]
        11709 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11709
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741003562
        ]
        11518 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11518
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741027401
        ]
        991 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 991
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741083891
        ]
        11299 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11299
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741085804
        ]
        11678 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11678
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741086468
        ]
        5923 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 5923
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741098993
        ]
        11463 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11463
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741107597
        ]
        11817 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11817
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741107730
        ]
        11827 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11827
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741111823
        ]
        603 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 603
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741120780
        ]
        10294 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10294
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741163926
        ]
        7401 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7401
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741167243
        ]
        11874 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11874
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741189108
        ]
        6358 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6358
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741192780
        ]
        743 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 743
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741192785
        ]
        10933 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10933
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741194352
        ]
        11891 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11891
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741200779
        ]
        10697 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 10697
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741218126
          "date_scan" => 1744101973
        ]
        1285 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1285
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741220423
        ]
        11434 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11434
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741255056
        ]
        7644 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7644
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741257634
        ]
        11382 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 11382
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741258308
          "date_scan" => 1744100786
        ]
        11973 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11973
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741279198
        ]
        11881 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11881
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741295746
        ]
        12003 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12003
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741315780
        ]
        12004 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12004
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741322495
        ]
        12007 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12007
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741327682
          "date_scan" => 1744101762
        ]
        7824 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 7824
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741341793
        ]
        11613 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11613
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741356823
        ]
        3540 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3540
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741414612
        ]
        9898 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9898
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1743974083
        ]
        12084 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12084
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741425394
          "date_scan" => 1744099312
        ]
        12099 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12099
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741600261
          "date_scan" => 1744101002
        ]
        12108 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12108
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741522924
          "date_scan" => 1744101505
        ]
        12137 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12137
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741607089
        ]
        5561 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 5561
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741607268
          "date_scan" => 1744105607
        ]
        12168 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12168
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741614388
          "date_scan" => 1744100773
        ]
        2952 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2952
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741617092
        ]
        11196 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11196
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741622002
        ]
        4721 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 4721
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741624723
          "date_scan" => 1744101526
        ]
        8876 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8876
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741685882
        ]
        11352 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11352
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741696967
        ]
        12125 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12125
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741701005
          "date_scan" => 1744100032
        ]
        12273 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12273
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741703410
          "date_scan" => 1744102631
        ]
        12270 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12270
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741703717
          "date_scan" => 1744102604
        ]
        12277 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12277
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741709839
        ]
        3978 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3978
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741712567
        ]
        12287 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12287
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741714535
        ]
        9326 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 9326
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741754910
        ]
        11883 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11883
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741772467
        ]
        12340 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12340
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741776915
          "date_scan" => 1744100740
        ]
        1750 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 1750
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741788719
        ]
        12367 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 12367
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741802602
          "date_scan" => 1744106244
        ]
        12390 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12390
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741804057
        ]
        540 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 540
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741858045
          "date_scan" => 1744101034
        ]
        8246 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8246
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741863513
        ]
        2886 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 2886
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741863748
        ]
        6933 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 6933
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741863887
          "date_scan" => 1744102465
        ]
        2391 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 2391
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741864557
          "date_scan" => 1744101198
        ]
        1886 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 1886
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741873392
          "date_scan" => 1744100903
        ]
        12175 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12175
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741878280
        ]
        10831 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10831
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741881223
        ]
        11559 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11559
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741884081
        ]
        3734 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 3734
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741964214
        ]
        12286 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12286
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1741974903
        ]
        8707 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 8707
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742051656
        ]
        11154 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 11154
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_scan" => 1744101028
        ]
        5754 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 5754
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742113554
          "date_scan" => 1744101192
        ]
        6315 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 6315
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742114086
          "date_scan" => 1744101191
        ]
        7080 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 7080
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742217123
          "date_scan" => 1744101360
        ]
        11750 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11750
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742217288
        ]
        12369 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12369
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742227679
        ]
        11567 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 11567
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742284316
        ]
        12779 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12779
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1743489526
        ]
        12777 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12777
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742309568
        ]
        6253 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 6253
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742403538
        ]
        910 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 910
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => true
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742324172
        ]
        12812 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12812
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742354358
        ]
        7282 => array:6 [
          "userID" => 7282
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1744018216
          "date_scan" => 1744101015
        ]
        12836 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 12836
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742479131
        ]
        4041 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 4041
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742386824
        ]
        10200 => array:5 [
          "userID" => 10200
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => false
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1742412912
        ]
        7716 => array:5 [ …5]
        10739 => array:5 [ …5]
        12985 => array:5 [ …5]
        3897 => array:5 [ …5]
        13000 => array:6 [ …6]
        13010 => array:5 [ …5]
        644 => array:5 [ …5]
        6097 => array:5 [ …5]
        6585 => array:5 [ …5]
        598 => array:5 [ …5]
        13041 => array:5 [ …5]
        11430 => array:5 [ …5]
        11019 => array:5 [ …5]
        12636 => array:5 [ …5]
        12460 => array:5 [ …5]
        13139 => array:5 [ …5]
        13179 => array:6 [ …6]
        13186 => array:5 [ …5]
        12110 => array:6 [ …6]
        13197 => array:6 [ …6]
        13200 => array:5 [ …5]
        6044 => array:5 [ …5]
        6698 => array:5 [ …5]
        13233 => array:5 [ …5]
        10524 => array:6 [ …6]
        11596 => array:5 [ …5]
        3122 => array:5 [ …5]
        12298 => array:5 [ …5]
        13252 => array:5 [ …5]
        2380 => array:5 [ …5]
        13291 => array:5 [ …5]
        11128 => array:5 [ …5]
        1414 => array:5 [ …5]
        13348 => array:5 [ …5]
        10765 => array:5 [ …5]
        8865 => array:5 [ …5]
        10289 => array:5 [ …5]
        6246 => array:5 [ …5]
        5966 => array:5 [ …5]
        4278 => array:5 [ …5]
        13467 => array:5 [ …5]
        2004 => array:5 [ …5]
        1926 => array:5 [ …5]
        9138 => array:5 [ …5]
        13494 => array:6 [ …6]
        1697 => array:6 [ …6]
        6932 => array:5 [ …5]
        10963 => array:5 [ …5]
        13380 => array:5 [ …5]
        2482 => array:6 [ …6]
        7049 => array:6 [ …6]
        4266 => array:5 [ …5]
        2449 => array:5 [ …5]
        13540 => array:5 [ …5]
        1006 => array:6 [ …6]
        13573 => array:5 [ …5]
        13572 => array:5 [ …5]
        11639 => array:5 [ …5]
        13497 => array:6 [ …6]
        13742 => array:5 [ …5]
        11249 => array:5 [ …5]
        11967 => array:5 [ …5]
        13745 => array:5 [ …5]
        6604 => array:6 [ …6]
        13599 => array:5 [ …5]
        13823 => array:5 [ …5]
        7343 => array:5 [ …5]
        6833 => array:5 [ …5]
        2265 => array:5 [ …5]
        13861 => array:6 [ …6]
        11885 => array:5 [ …5]
        11640 => array:5 [ …5]
        13514 => array:5 [ …5]
        13445 => array:5 [ …5]
        12240 => array:5 [ …5]
        13451 => array:5 [ …5]
        6138 => array:5 [ …5]
        7957 => array:5 [ …5]
        13630 => array:5 [ …5]
        9228 => array:5 [ …5]
        14018 => array:5 [ …5]
        10829 => array:5 [ …5]
        13357 => array:5 [ …5]
        14059 => array:5 [ …5]
        11819 => array:5 [ …5]
        12267 => array:5 [ …5]
        13977 => array:5 [ …5]
        13096 => array:6 [ …6]
        6434 => array:6 [ …6]
        13923 => array:5 [ …5]
        13821 => array:5 [ …5]
        14116 => array:5 [ …5]
        12688 => array:5 [ …5]
      ]
      +"stats": {#4177
        +"total": "206"
        +"accepted": 190
        +"pending": 0
        +"declined": 202
        +"cancelled": 0
        +"waiting": 0
        +"in_person": 190
        +"online": 0
        +"checked_in": 0
        +"left": 16
      }
    }
    "realHostSpeakers" => []
    "userID" => "2575"
    "user" => WP_User {#4634
      +data: {#4636
        +"ID": "2575"
        +"user_login": "ziad@obeidpartners.com"
        +"user_pass": "$P$BW1ks1WqgmFx2cNEWNAAle5axX6vUF/"
        +"user_nicename": "ziadobeidpartners-com"
        +"user_email": "ziad@obeidpartners.com"
        +"user_url": ""
        +"user_registered": "2023-02-23 13:14:42"
        +"user_activation_key": ""
        +"user_status": "0"
        +"display_name": "Ziad Obeid"
        +"review": ""
        +"state": "published"
        +"first_name": "Ziad"
        +"last_name": "OBEID"
        +"full_name": "Ziad OBEID"
        +"civility": "Mr"
        +"description": """
          Managing Partner at Obeid & Partners, Ziad Obeid is a dual-qualified lawyer with a civil engineering background and extensive cross-border experience gained through legal practice in Europe and the Middle East.\r\n
          \r\n
          Identified among the world’s foremost dispute resolution practitioners in GAR’s Thought Leaders 2020, Ziad has notable expertise in international arbitration and cross-border dispute resolution proceedings. His experience covers cases brought under bilateral investment treaties, international legal instruments and contractual provisions across the real estate, reinsurance, construction, oil and gas, nuclear, power generation and telecoms sectors. He also advises on diverse public international law issues. He regularly acts as counsel, sole arbitrator, chairperson, or co-arbitrator in multifaceted international arbitrations conducted in Arabic, French, and English brought both ad hoc and under a variety of institutional rules and subject to a wide range of applicable laws from within the MENA region and beyond.
          """
        +"citation": ""
        +"citationAuthor": ""
        +"company": ""
        +"companyID": "4776"
        +"job": "Managing Partner"
        +"status": "1"
        +"phone": "+9613335999"
        +"country": "Lebanon"
        +"city": ""
        +"twitter": ""
        +"linkedin": "https://www.linkedin.com/in/ziadobeid/"
        +"default_paw_networking": ""
        +"avatar": "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/me--ziad-obeid-photo.jpg"
        +"rang": ""
        +"activity": "law_firm"
        +"themes": array:1 [ …1]
        +"companyName": "Obeid &amp; Partners"
        +"favorites": []
      }
      +ID: 2575
      +caps: array:1 [
        "speaker" => true
      ]
      +cap_key: "wp_capabilities"
      +roles: array:1 [
        0 => "speaker"
      ]
      +allcaps: array:2 [
        "read" => true
        "speaker" => true
      ]
      +filter: null
      -site_id: 1
    }
    "realGuestSpeakers" => array:4 [
      0 => 10293
      1 => 10294
      2 => 10295
      3 => 2575
    ]
    "partner" => WP_Post {#4585
      +ID: 4368
      +post_author: "15035"
      +post_date: "2026-04-21 07:03:37"
      +post_date_gmt: "2026-04-21 07:03:37"
      +post_content: """
        FTI Consulting is the leading global expert firm for organizations facing crisis and transformation, with more than 8,100 employees in 32 countries. We support clients to address their most critical and complex changes, risks and disputes with professionals located across the world.\r\n
        \r\n
        In the world of arbitrations, organizations facing commercial or international disputes often require valuation opinions, expert testimony and damages calculations. Around the globe, FTI Consulting is regarded as the leading firm in the areas of finance, economics and accounting that undergird the provision of damages expertise. \r\n
        \r\n
        FTI Consulting professionals provide clear, reliable and objective advice — in matters ranging from discovery and investigation to expert witness testimony and damages quantification — to courts and tribunals, parties to disputes and their legal counsel.\u{202F} \r\n
        FTI Consulting’s experts support global clients in dealing with disputes of all kinds, including claims in intellectual property, labor and employment, class actions, securities litigation and complex commercial and regulatory disputes that require industry specific knowledge.\r\n
        The international team also supports trials, hearings and arbitrations (in person and remote) with evidence presentation technology and graphics. \r\n
        \r\n
        Find out more at fticonsulting.com/france
        """
      +post_title: "FTI Consulting"
      +post_excerpt: ""
      +post_status: "publish"
      +comment_status: "closed"
      +ping_status: "closed"
      +post_password: ""
      +post_name: "fti-consulting"
      +to_ping: ""
      +pinged: ""
      +post_modified: "2026-04-21 07:03:37"
      +post_modified_gmt: "2026-04-21 07:03:37"
      +post_content_filtered: ""
      +post_parent: 0
      +guid: "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/partner/fti-consulting/"
      +menu_order: 0
      +post_type: "partner"
      +post_mime_type: ""
      +comment_count: "0"
      +filter: "raw"
      +"review": ""
      +"state": "online"
      +"paymentCustomer": ""
      +"paymentURL": ""
      +"paymentID": ""
      +"paymentStatus": "valid"
      +"paymentInvoiceNumber": ""
      +"paymentInvoiceDate": ""
      +"category": "expert_firm"
      +"type": "paying_big"
      +"logos": array:1 [
        0 => "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/5-8c91b4cf34801a0f50f49fc1e3b236a3/2023/01/.fti_logo_blue_jpg.jpg"
      ]
      +"citation": ""
      +"citationAuthor": ""
      +"website": "https://www.fticonsulting.com/fr-fr/france"
      +"linkedin": "https://www.linkedin.com/showcase/fti-consulting-france/"
      +"twiter": ""
      +"contactEmail": "laetitia.brin@fticonsulting.com"
      +"address": {#4538
        +"street1": "10 rue de Bassano"
        +"street2": ""
        +"street": "10 rue de Bassano "
        +"postcode": "75116"
        +"city": "Paris"
        +"country": "France"
        +"legal_entity": "FTI France SAS"
        +"billing_street1": ""
        +"billing_street2": ""
        +"billing_street": " "
        +"billing_postcode": ""
        +"billing_city": ""
        +"billing_country": ""
      }
      +"masterUsers": array:1 [
        0 => "15035"
      ]
      +"speakerHosts": array:5 [
        0 => "1529"
        1 => "10255"
        2 => "1250"
        3 => "2806"
        4 => "641"
      ]
      +"speakerGuests": array:25 [
        0 => "1238"
        1 => "3506"
        2 => "2949"
        3 => "1273"
        4 => "3672"
        5 => "1627"
        6 => "1889"
        7 => "2603"
        8 => "8744"
        9 => "9329"
        10 => "9341"
        11 => "10293"
        12 => "10294"
        13 => "10295"
        14 => "2575"
        15 => "10744"
        16 => "1682"
        17 => "1592"
        18 => "15446"
        19 => "3780"
        20 => "15480"
        21 => "2327"
        22 => "10897"
        23 => "3070"
        24 => "9609"
      ]
      +"strategic": {#4591
        +"lastname": "Gady"
        +"firstname": "Marion"
        +"email": "marion.gady@fticonsulting.com"
        +"phone": "+33613161230"
        +"job": "Managing Director"
        +"civility": "Ms"
      }
      +"otherContacts": array:5 [
        0 => array:7 [ …7]
        1 => array:7 [ …7]
        2 => array:7 [ …7]
        3 => array:7 [ …7]
        4 => array:7 [ …7]
      ]
      +"editions": array:4 [
        0 => "40615"
        1 => "39376"
        2 => "13223"
        3 => "13224"
      ]
      +"currentEvents": array:2 [
        0 => 40892
        1 => 40893
      ]
    }
    "can_see_participants" => false
    "showAllParticipants" => false
    "isAccepted" => null
    "isPending" => null
    "isDeclined" => null
    "isWaiting" => null
    "status_class" => null
  ]
  "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
  "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
  "override" => "app"
  "display_sidebar" => false
  "notices" => []
  "browser" => null
  "displayArchiveStructs" => true
  "relatedEdition" => WP_Post {#4176}
  "edition_dates" => "23 - 27 March 2026"
  "static_pages" => array:9 [
    "middle_office" => "89"
    "digital_library" => "13219"
    "legal_notice" => "955"
    "privacy_statement" => "12766"
    "contact_us" => "95"
    "sign_in" => "424"
    "visitor_register" => "40592"
    "partner_register" => "28"
    "maintenance" => "40491"
  ]
  "event" => WP_Post {#4181}
  "realHostSpeakers" => []
  "userID" => "2575"
  "user" => WP_User {#4634}
  "realGuestSpeakers" => array:4 [
    0 => 10293
    1 => 10294
    2 => 10295
    3 => 2575
  ]
  "partner" => WP_Post {#4585}
  "can_see_participants" => false
  "showAllParticipants" => false
  "isAccepted" => null
  "isPending" => null
  "isDeclined" => null
  "isWaiting" => null
  "status_class" => null
]