To register for this event, please login or create your visitor account.

Monday
27 March
2023
14:30 to 16:30
HYBRID
BY REQUEST
Monday 27 March 2023
14:30 to 16:30

Replay

Please log in to your PAW account to view the video.

Presentation

Dispositive motions, common practice in the United States, are gaining traction in the wider international arbitration community, making their way into several different global institutional rules. They are, however, less commonly used in civil law jurisdictions.

Summary or dispositive proceedings are often promoted as tools to accelerate the resolution of a claim, promote efficiency, and conserve judicial resources. Despite these goals, do they live up to their extolled virtues in practice?

Join Reed Smith global presenters and our star-studded panel of guest speakers gathered from near and far for a lively discussion exploring the value and efficiency of dispositive motions – covering the good, the bad, and the ugly – and looking at example case studies that may or may not benefit from dispositive motions. The discussion will also examine the ongoing debate on whether dispositive motions could violate the New York Convention’s presentment clause.

Guest speakers:

- Patrick Baeten (Chief Legal Officer M&A – Engie)
- Stefan Brocker (Partner, Mannheimer Swartling)
- Felix Dasser (President of the Swiss Arbitration Association)
- Harriet O'Neill (Retired Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of Texas)
- Edna Sussman (Arbitrator, Mediator)

Reed Smith presenters:

- Peter Rosher - Paris, Global Chair of International Arbitration
- Antonia Birt - Dubai, Partner
- Matthew Townsend - Hong Kong, Partner
- Daniel Ávila II - Houston, Associate

Host Speakers

Peter ROSHER
Global Chair of International Arbitration
Rosher Arbitration
Antonia BIRT
Partner
Reed Smith
Matthew TOWNSEND
Partner / (Foreign Registered Lawyer)
Reed Smith
Daniel AVILA
Associate
Reed Smith

Guest Speakers

Edna SUSSMAN
Arbitrator, Mediator, Principal at SussmanADR LLC
SussmanADR
Stefan BROCKER
Partner
Mannheimer Swartling
Felix DASSER
President of the Swiss Arbitration Association and Partner with Homburger
Swiss Arbitration Association
Harriet O'NEILL
Retired Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of Texas
Law Office of Harriet O'Neill
Patrick BAETEN
Chief Legal Officer M&A
Engie

Venue


112 Av. Kléber
75116 Paris

Select a participation mode

then click on the register button below.

Registration for this event is now closed.

 array:25 [
  "__path" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache/c84ebf1432a129894c6a5ed11ec848552cf558ba.php"
  "__data" => array:23 [
    "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419
      #engines: Illuminate\View\Engines\EngineResolver {#2411
        #resolvers: array:3 [
          "file" => Closure() {#2412 …2}
          "php" => Closure() {#2413 …2}
          "blade" => Closure() {#2414 …2}
        ]
        #resolved: array:1 [
          "blade" => Illuminate\View\Engines\CompilerEngine {#4174 …3}
        ]
      }
      #finder: Illuminate\View\FileViewFinder {#2415
        #files: Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
        #paths: array:1 [
          0 => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views"
        ]
        #views: array:21 [
          "single-event" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/single-event.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.section-top" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/section-top.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.section-left" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/section-left.blade.php"
          "partials.event-format" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/event-format.blade.php"
          "partials.event-type" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/event-type.blade.php"
          "partials.entry-sharer" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/entry-sharer.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.section-right" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/section-right.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.medias" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/medias.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.section-bottom" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/section-bottom.blade.php"
          "partials.user-thumbnail" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/user-thumbnail.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.venue" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/venue.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.how-to-attend" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/how-to-attend.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.online" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/online.blade.php"
          "partials.single-event.register" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/single-event/register.blade.php"
          "layouts.app-left-right" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/layouts/app-left-right.blade.php"
          "structs.head" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/head.blade.php"
          "structs.header" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/header.blade.php"
          "partials.notices" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/notices.blade.php"
          "partials.breadcrumbs" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/breadcrumbs.blade.php"
          "structs.footer" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/footer.blade.php"
          "partials.nav-social" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/nav-social.blade.php"
        ]
        #hints: []
        #extensions: array:4 [
          0 => "blade.php"
          1 => "php"
          2 => "css"
          3 => "html"
        ]
      }
      #events: Illuminate\Events\Dispatcher {#2417
        #container: Illuminate\Container\Container {#2418
          #resolved: []
          #bindings: []
          #methodBindings: []
          #instances: []
          #scopedInstances: []
          #aliases: []
          #abstractAliases: []
          #extenders: []
          #tags: []
          #buildStack: []
          #with: []
          +contextual: []
          #reboundCallbacks: []
          #globalBeforeResolvingCallbacks: []
          #globalResolvingCallbacks: []
          #globalAfterResolvingCallbacks: []
          #beforeResolvingCallbacks: []
          #resolvingCallbacks: []
          #afterResolvingCallbacks: []
        }
        #listeners: []
        #wildcards: []
        #wildcardsCache: array:42 [
          "creating: single-event" => []
          "composing: single-event" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.section-top" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.section-top" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.section-left" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.section-left" => []
          "creating: partials.event-format" => []
          "composing: partials.event-format" => []
          "creating: partials.event-type" => []
          "composing: partials.event-type" => []
          "creating: partials.entry-sharer" => []
          "composing: partials.entry-sharer" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.section-right" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.section-right" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.medias" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.medias" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.section-bottom" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.section-bottom" => []
          "creating: partials.user-thumbnail" => []
          "composing: partials.user-thumbnail" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.venue" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.venue" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.how-to-attend" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.how-to-attend" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.online" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.online" => []
          "creating: partials.single-event.register" => []
          "composing: partials.single-event.register" => []
          "creating: layouts.app-left-right" => []
          "composing: layouts.app-left-right" => []
          "creating: structs.head" => []
          "composing: structs.head" => []
          "creating: structs.header" => []
          "composing: structs.header" => []
          "creating: partials.notices" => []
          "composing: partials.notices" => []
          "creating: partials.breadcrumbs" => []
          "composing: partials.breadcrumbs" => []
          "creating: structs.footer" => []
          "composing: structs.footer" => []
          "creating: partials.nav-social" => []
          "composing: partials.nav-social" => []
        ]
        #queueResolver: null
      }
      #container: Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401
        #resolved: array:7 [
          "view.engine.resolver" => true
          "files" => true
          "config" => true
          "view.finder" => true
          "events" => true
          "view" => true
          "blade.compiler" => true
        ]
        #bindings: array:7 [
          "files" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2403 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "events" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2404 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "config" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2405 …3}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2407 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view.finder" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2408 …2}
            "shared" => false
          ]
          "blade.compiler" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2409 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view.engine.resolver" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2410 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
        ]
        #methodBindings: []
        #instances: array:6 [
          "view.engine.resolver" => Illuminate\View\Engines\EngineResolver {#2411}
          "files" => Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
          "config" => array:2 [
            "view.paths" => array:1 [ …1]
            "view.compiled" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache"
          ]
          "events" => Illuminate\Events\Dispatcher {#2417}
          "view" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
          "blade.compiler" => Illuminate\View\Compilers\BladeCompiler {#2420
            #files: Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
            #cachePath: "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache"
            #extensions: []
            #customDirectives: array:4 [ …4]
            #conditions: []
            #precompilers: []
            #path: null
            #compilers: array:3 [ …3]
            #rawTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #contentTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #escapedTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #echoFormat: "e(%s)"
            #footer: []
            #rawBlocks: []
            #classComponentAliases: array:1 [ …1]
            #classComponentNamespaces: []
            #compilesComponentTags: true
            #firstCaseInSwitch: true
            #echoHandlers: []
            -encodingOptions: 15
            #lastSection: null
            #forElseCounter: 0
          }
        ]
        #scopedInstances: []
        #aliases: []
        #abstractAliases: []
        #extenders: []
        #tags: []
        #buildStack: []
        #with: []
        +contextual: []
        #reboundCallbacks: []
        #globalBeforeResolvingCallbacks: []
        #globalResolvingCallbacks: []
        #globalAfterResolvingCallbacks: []
        #beforeResolvingCallbacks: []
        #resolvingCallbacks: []
        #afterResolvingCallbacks: []
      }
      #shared: array:2 [
        "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
        "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
      ]
      #extensions: array:4 [
        "blade.php" => "blade"
        "php" => "php"
        "css" => "file"
        "html" => "file"
      ]
      #composers: []
      #renderCount: 3
      #renderedOnce: []
      #componentStack: []
      #componentData: []
      #currentComponentData: []
      #slots: []
      #slotStack: []
      #sections: array:4 [
        "content-top" => """
              <div class="wrapper">\n
              <div class="event-status ">\n
                  <div class="event-status_ctn">\n
                                                          <p>To register for this event, please login or create your visitor account.</p>\n
                              <a class="button signin-event is-style-primary-white" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/sign-in/">\n
                                  <span>\n
                                      Sign in\n
                                      <i class="paw-icon-arrow"></i>\n
                                  </span>\n
                              </a>\n
                                              </div>\n
              </div>\n
          </div>
          """
        "content-left" => """
              <div class="event-details is-hidden-touch">\n
              \n
              <div class="event-date">\n
                  <div>Monday</div>\n
                  <div>27 March</div>\n
                  <div>2023</div>\n
              </div>\n
              \n
              \n
              <div class="event-time">14:30 to 16:30</div>\n
          \n
              \n
              <div class="event-format">\n
              <div class="term">\n
                  <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="18.963" height="15.282" viewBox="0 0 18.963 15.282">\r\n
            <g transform="translate(0 0)">\r\n
              <path d="M6.622,6.3a.231.231,0,0,1,0,.327L.394,12.85A.231.231,0,0,1,0,12.687V.232A.231.231,0,0,1,.394.068Z" transform="translate(12.918 8.592) rotate(90)" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
              <path d="M6.622,6.3a.231.231,0,0,1,0,.327L.394,12.85A.231.231,0,0,1,0,12.687V.232A.231.231,0,0,1,.394.068Z" transform="translate(6.045 6.689) rotate(-90)" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
            </g>\r\n
          </svg>\r\n
          \n
                  HYBRID\n
              </div>\n
          </div>\n
              \n
              \n
              <div class="event-type">\n
              <div class="term">\n
                  BY REQUEST\n
              </div>\n
          </div>\n
                  \n
              \n
              \n
                      <div class="partner-contact" style="margin-top: 20px">\n
                      <button id="gf_button_get_form_6ac8dceb11114" class="contact button">Contact the Organiser</button><script>\n
                      (function () {\n
                          var initAjaxButton = function() {\n
                              jQuery('#gf_button_get_form_6ac8dceb11114').click(function(){\n
                                  var button = jQuery(this);\n
                                  let modal = $('.modal.global');\n
                                  let modalCtn = modal.find('.modal-content');\n
                                  \n
                                  jQuery.get('https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php?action=show_contact_partner_form&form_id=18&partner_id=605',function(response){\n
                                      modalCtn.empty();\n
                                      modalCtn.append(response);\n
                                      modal.addClass('is-active');\n
                                      modal.trigger('classChange');\n
                                      if(window['gformInitDatepicker']) {gformInitDatepicker();}\n
                                      /*\n
                                      if('show_contact_partner_form' === 'add_rsvp') {\n
                                          $('.gform_heading').append('<h2>Send a RSVP invitation</h2>');\n
                                      } else if('show_contact_partner_form' === 'add_visitor') {\n
                                          $('.gform_heading').append('<h2>Add an Attendee</h2>');\n
                                      }\n
                                      */\n
                                  });\n
                              });\n
                          };\n
                          window.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', initAjaxButton);\n
                      }());\n
                  </script>\n
                  </div>\n
                  \n
              \n
              <div class="entry-sharer ">\n
              <div class="share-container">\n
                <button\n
                  aria-label="Partager"\n
                  class="share-button"\n
                  data-title="Summary Dispositions in International Arbitration – an important tool or just going through the (dispositive) motions?"\n
                  data-excerpt="Dispositive motions, common practice in the United States, are gaining traction in the [&hellip;]"\n
                  data-url="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/summary-dispositions-in-international-arbitration-an-important-tool-or-just-going-through-the-dispositive-motions/"\n
                  >\n
                      <span>Share\n
                          <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="16.32" height="18.157" viewBox="0 0 16.32 18.157">\r\n
            <g>\r\n
              <path d="M13.072,11.714a3.13,3.13,0,0,0-2.423,1.118L6.123,10.489a3.137,3.137,0,0,0,.319-1.411,3.535,3.535,0,0,0-.319-1.411l4.526-2.343a3.171,3.171,0,0,0,2.423,1.118,3.221,3.221,0,1,0,0-6.443A3.278,3.278,0,0,0,9.85,3.275a3.389,3.389,0,0,0,.213,1.171L5.458,6.815a3.179,3.179,0,0,0-2.263-.932,3.221,3.221,0,0,0,.027,6.443,3.179,3.179,0,0,0,2.263-.932l4.606,2.369a3.389,3.389,0,0,0-.213,1.171,3.221,3.221,0,1,0,3.195-3.221m0-10.569a2.156,2.156,0,1,1-2.156,2.13,2.142,2.142,0,0,1,2.156-2.13M3.221,11.261A2.156,2.156,0,1,1,5.378,9.1a2.182,2.182,0,0,1-2.156,2.156m9.85,5.8a2.156,2.156,0,1,1,2.156-2.156,2.164,2.164,0,0,1-2.156,2.156" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
            </g>\r\n
          </svg>\r\n
                      </span>\n
                </button>\n
              </div>\n
          \n
                      <div class="favorite-container">\n
                      <button class="fav "\n
                          data-nonce="6a03838bfb" data-id="3408"\n
                          aria-label="Add to favorite"\n
                          title="Add to my favourites">\n
                          <span class="star">\n
                              <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" viewBox="0 0 30 30">\n
            <g>\n
              <path class="fav-outline" fill-rule="evenodd" fill="currentColor" d="M15.84,7.4l1.94,4.76,5.13.38c.35.03.61.33.59.68-.01.17-.09.33-.22.44l-3.92,3.32,1.22,4.99c.03.12.02.25-.02.37h0c-.12.33-.49.5-.82.38-.04-.01-.08-.03-.12-.06l-4.37-2.71-4.37,2.71c-.3.18-.69.09-.88-.21-.02-.04-.04-.08-.06-.12h0c-.04-.12-.05-.25-.02-.37l1.22-4.99-3.93-3.32c-.27-.23-.3-.63-.07-.9.11-.13.27-.21.44-.22l5.13-.38,1.94-4.75c.13-.33.5-.48.83-.35.16.06.29.19.35.35ZM17.1,12.71l-1.85-4.53-1.95,4.78-5.14.38,3.94,3.33-1.23,5.01,4.38-2.72,4.38,2.72-1.23-5.01,3.93-3.33-5.14-.38-.1-.24Z"/>\n
              <path class="fav-filled" fill="currentColor" d="M15.84,7.4l1.94,4.76,5.13.38c.35.03.61.33.59.68-.01.17-.09.33-.22.44l-3.92,3.32,1.22,4.99c.03.12.02.25-.02.37h0c-.12.33-.49.5-.82.38-.04-.01-.08-.03-.12-.06l-4.37-2.71-4.37,2.71c-.3.18-.69.09-.88-.21-.02-.04-.04-.08-.06-.12h0c-.04-.12-.05-.25-.02-.37l1.22-4.99-3.93-3.32c-.27-.23-.3-.63-.07-.9.11-.13.27-.21.44-.22l5.13-.38,1.94-4.75c.13-.33.5-.48.83-.35.16.06.29.19.35.35Z"/>\n
            </g>\n
          </svg>                </span>\n
                      </button>\n
                  </div>\n
              </div></div>
          """
        "content-right" => """
              <div class="page-header">\n
              <div class="event-category">\n
                  [Academic]\n
              </div>\n
              <h1>Summary Dispositions in International Arbitration – an important tool or just going through the (dispositive) motions?</h1>\n
              <div class="event-terms">\n
                              <a class="theme" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/theme/commercial-arbitration/">\n
                          #Commercial arbitration\n
                      </a>\n
                              <a class="theme" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/theme/investment-arbitration/">\n
                          #Investment arbitration\n
                      </a>\n
                              </div>\n
          </div>\n
          \n
          <div class="event-details is-hidden-desktop">\n
              <div class="event-date">Monday 27 March 2023</div>\n
              \n
              \n
                      \n
                  <div></div>\n
              \n
              \n
              <div class="event-time">14:30 to 16:30</div>\n
              \n
              \n
              <div class="entry-sharer ">\n
              <div class="share-container">\n
                <button\n
                  aria-label="Partager"\n
                  class="share-button"\n
                  data-title="Summary Dispositions in International Arbitration – an important tool or just going through the (dispositive) motions?"\n
                  data-excerpt="Dispositive motions, common practice in the United States, are gaining traction in the [&hellip;]"\n
                  data-url="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/summary-dispositions-in-international-arbitration-an-important-tool-or-just-going-through-the-dispositive-motions/"\n
                  >\n
                      <span>Share\n
                          <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" width="16.32" height="18.157" viewBox="0 0 16.32 18.157">\r\n
            <g>\r\n
              <path d="M13.072,11.714a3.13,3.13,0,0,0-2.423,1.118L6.123,10.489a3.137,3.137,0,0,0,.319-1.411,3.535,3.535,0,0,0-.319-1.411l4.526-2.343a3.171,3.171,0,0,0,2.423,1.118,3.221,3.221,0,1,0,0-6.443A3.278,3.278,0,0,0,9.85,3.275a3.389,3.389,0,0,0,.213,1.171L5.458,6.815a3.179,3.179,0,0,0-2.263-.932,3.221,3.221,0,0,0,.027,6.443,3.179,3.179,0,0,0,2.263-.932l4.606,2.369a3.389,3.389,0,0,0-.213,1.171,3.221,3.221,0,1,0,3.195-3.221m0-10.569a2.156,2.156,0,1,1-2.156,2.13,2.142,2.142,0,0,1,2.156-2.13M3.221,11.261A2.156,2.156,0,1,1,5.378,9.1a2.182,2.182,0,0,1-2.156,2.156m9.85,5.8a2.156,2.156,0,1,1,2.156-2.156,2.164,2.164,0,0,1-2.156,2.156" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
            </g>\r\n
          </svg>\r\n
                      </span>\n
                </button>\n
              </div>\n
          \n
                      <div class="favorite-container">\n
                      <button class="fav "\n
                          data-nonce="6a03838bfb" data-id="3408"\n
                          aria-label="Add to favorite"\n
                          title="Add to my favourites">\n
                          <span class="star">\n
                              <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" viewBox="0 0 30 30">\n
            <g>\n
              <path class="fav-outline" fill-rule="evenodd" fill="currentColor" d="M15.84,7.4l1.94,4.76,5.13.38c.35.03.61.33.59.68-.01.17-.09.33-.22.44l-3.92,3.32,1.22,4.99c.03.12.02.25-.02.37h0c-.12.33-.49.5-.82.38-.04-.01-.08-.03-.12-.06l-4.37-2.71-4.37,2.71c-.3.18-.69.09-.88-.21-.02-.04-.04-.08-.06-.12h0c-.04-.12-.05-.25-.02-.37l1.22-4.99-3.93-3.32c-.27-.23-.3-.63-.07-.9.11-.13.27-.21.44-.22l5.13-.38,1.94-4.75c.13-.33.5-.48.83-.35.16.06.29.19.35.35ZM17.1,12.71l-1.85-4.53-1.95,4.78-5.14.38,3.94,3.33-1.23,5.01,4.38-2.72,4.38,2.72-1.23-5.01,3.93-3.33-5.14-.38-.1-.24Z"/>\n
              <path class="fav-filled" fill="currentColor" d="M15.84,7.4l1.94,4.76,5.13.38c.35.03.61.33.59.68-.01.17-.09.33-.22.44l-3.92,3.32,1.22,4.99c.03.12.02.25-.02.37h0c-.12.33-.49.5-.82.38-.04-.01-.08-.03-.12-.06l-4.37-2.71-4.37,2.71c-.3.18-.69.09-.88-.21-.02-.04-.04-.08-.06-.12h0c-.04-.12-.05-.25-.02-.37l1.22-4.99-3.93-3.32c-.27-.23-.3-.63-.07-.9.11-.13.27-.21.44-.22l5.13-.38,1.94-4.75c.13-.33.5-.48.83-.35.16.06.29.19.35.35Z"/>\n
            </g>\n
          </svg>                </span>\n
                      </button>\n
                  </div>\n
              </div></div>\n
          \n
          <div class="partner-company">\n
                                      <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/partner/reed-smith/">\n
                          <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/reed-smith_logo_paw.png" alt="Logo partner">\n
                      </a>\n
                      \n
              </div>\n
          \n
              <div class="event-replay">\n
                  <h3 class="mt-0 is-style-h2">\n
                      Replay\n
                  </h3>\n
                              <div class="event-video mb-6">\n
                                              <p>Please log in to your PAW account to view the video. \n
                                  <a class="text signin-event" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/sign-in/">\n
                                      Sign in.\n
                                  </a>\n
                              </p>\n
                                      </div>\n
                  \n
                  \n
                              <div class="event-photos">\n
                          <div class="photos-gallery swiper-container">\n
                              <div class="swiper-wrapper">\n
                                                                                              <a class="swiper-slide" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-d.jpg" data-external-thumb="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-d.jpg">\n
                                              <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-d.jpg" alt="">\n
                                          </a>\n
                                                                                                                          <a class="swiper-slide" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-b.jpg" data-external-thumb="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-b.jpg">\n
                                              <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-b.jpg" alt="">\n
                                          </a>\n
                                                                                                                          <a class="swiper-slide" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-f.jpg" data-external-thumb="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-f.jpg">\n
                                              <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-f.jpg" alt="">\n
                                          </a>\n
                                                                                                                          <a class="swiper-slide" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-bb.jpg" data-external-thumb="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-bb.jpg">\n
                                              <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-bb.jpg" alt="">\n
                                          </a>\n
                                                                                  </div>\n
                                                      <div class="swiper-navigation">\n
                                      <div class="swiper-button-prev">\n
                                          <i class="paw-icon-arrow"></i>\n
                                      </div>\n
                                      <div class="swiper-button-next">\n
                                          <i class="paw-icon-arrow"></i>\n
                                      </div>\n
                                  </div>\n
                                              </div>\n
                      </div>\n
                      </div>\n
          \n
                      <div class="event-presentation event-section box">\n
                      <h3 class="mt-0 is-style-h2">Presentation</h3>\n
                      <p>Dispositive motions, common practice in the United States, are gaining traction in the wider international arbitration community, making their way into several different global institutional rules. They are, however, less commonly used in civil law jurisdictions.</p>\n
          <p>Summary or dispositive proceedings are often promoted as tools to accelerate the resolution of a claim, promote efficiency, and conserve judicial resources. Despite these goals, do they live up to their extolled virtues in practice?</p>\n
          <p>Join Reed Smith global presenters and our star-studded panel of guest speakers gathered from near and far for a lively discussion exploring the value and efficiency of dispositive motions – covering the good, the bad, and the ugly – and looking at example case studies that may or may not benefit from dispositive motions. The discussion will also examine the ongoing debate on whether dispositive motions could violate the New York Convention’s presentment clause.</p>\n
          <p>Guest speakers:</p>\n
          <p>-          Patrick Baeten (Chief Legal Officer M&amp;A – Engie)<br />\n
          -          Stefan Brocker (Partner, Mannheimer Swartling)<br />\n
          -          Felix Dasser (President of the Swiss Arbitration Association)<br />\n
          -          Harriet O'Neill (Retired Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of Texas)<br />\n
          -          Edna Sussman (Arbitrator, Mediator)</p>\n
          <p>Reed Smith presenters:</p>\n
          <p>-          Peter Rosher - Paris, Global Chair of International Arbitration<br />\n
          -          Antonia Birt - Dubai, Partner<br />\n
          -          Matthew Townsend - Hong Kong, Partner<br />\n
          -          Daniel Ávila II - Houston, Associate</p>\n
          \n
                  </div>\n
              
          """
        "content-bottom" => """
                  <div class="event_speakers_hld event-section">\n
                  <h3 class="is-style-h2">Host Speakers</h3>\n
                  <div class="event-speakers">\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/peter-rosher-314/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/peter-rosher-reed-smith-1-361x361_314.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Peter ROSHER</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Global Chair of International Arbitration</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Rosher Arbitration</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/antonia-birt-315/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/birt-antonia-020848-marketing.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Antonia BIRT</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Partner</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Reed Smith</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/mtownsendreedsmith-com/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/mtownsend-358x358_316.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Matthew TOWNSEND</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Partner / (Foreign Registered Lawyer)</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Reed Smith</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/davilareedsmith-com/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/davila-456x456_317.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Daniel AVILA</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Associate</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Reed Smith</div>\n
              </div>\n
                              </div>\n
              </div>\n
          \n
              <div class="event_speakers_hld event-section">\n
                  <h3 class="is-style-h2">Guest Speakers</h3>\n
                  <div class="event-speakers">\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/esussmansussmanadr-com/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/edna-sussman-1245x1245_323.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Edna SUSSMAN</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Arbitrator, Mediator, Principal at SussmanADR LLC</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">SussmanADR</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/stefan-brockermsa-se/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/sborkcer-277x277_326.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Stefan BROCKER</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Partner</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Mannheimer Swartling</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/felix-dasserhomburger-ch/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/felix-dasser.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Felix DASSER</div>\n
                  <div class="job">President of the Swiss Arbitration Association and Partner with Homburger</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Swiss Arbitration Association</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/honeillharrietoneilllaw-com/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/harriet-oneill-237x237_329.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Harriet O&#039;NEILL</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Retired Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of Texas</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Law Office of Harriet O'Neill</div>\n
              </div>\n
                                      <div class="user">\n
                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/speakers/patrick-baetenengie-com/">\n
                                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/patrick-baeten-1065x1065_447.jpg" alt="" class="image">\n
                              </a>\n
                  <div class="fullname mt-4 mb-1">Patrick BAETEN</div>\n
                  <div class="job">Chief Legal Officer M&amp;A</div>\n
                  <div class="company mt-1">Engie</div>\n
              </div>\n
                              </div>\n
              </div>\n
          \n
          \n
          \n
          \n
              <div class="register-in_person event-venue event-section">\n
              <div class="event_address">\n
                  <h3 class="is-style-h2">Venue</h3>\n
                  <b></b><br>\n
                  112 Av. Kléber<br>\n
                  75116 Paris\n
                      </div>\n
              <div class="event_map">\n
                  <div class="maps"></div>\n
                  <iframe\n
                      width="520"\n
                      height="320"\n
                      frameborder="0" style="border:0"\n
                      referrerpolicy="no-referrer-when-downgrade"\n
                      src="https://www.google.com/maps/embed/v1/place?key=AIzaSyCykTSHbAIskoaDWw4hqClIH18XDau4D7k&q=112+Av.+Kléber,75116,Paris"\n
                      allowfullscreen\n
                      data-lenis-prevent\n
                      >\n
                  </iframe>\n
              </div>\n
          </div>\n
          \n
          <div id="register" class="event-registration event-section">\n
              <div>\n
                              <div class="event-attend aligncompact">\n
                                  <div class="event-registration-actions_hld">\n
                          <div>\n
                              <p class="is-style-h2 has-white-color">\n
                                  Select a participation mode\n
                              </p>\n
                              <p>\n
                                  then click on the register button below.\n
                              </p>\n
                          </div>\n
                          <div class="event-registration-actions">\n
                              <button class="choice button blue active" data-format="in_person" data-external="false">\n
                                  <span>In person</span>\n
                              </button>\n
                              <button class="choice button blue" data-format="online" data-external="false">\n
                                  <span>Online</span>\n
                              </button>\n
                          </div>\n
                      </div>\n
                      </div>        \n
                              <div class="register-online is-hidden">\n
              <h3>Online session</h3>\n
              <p>Webinar login information will be sent to you upon confirmation of your registration.</p>\n
              \n
              </div>        \n
                  <div class="event-register aligncompact">\n
                      <p class="has-text-align-center"><strong>\n
                      Registration for this event is now closed.\n
                  </strong></p>\n
              </div>    </div>\n
          </div>    
          """
      ]
      #sectionStack: []
      #loopsStack: []
      #pushes: []
      #prepends: []
      #pushStack: []
      #translationReplacements: []
    }
    "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
    "override" => "app"
    "display_sidebar" => false
    "notices" => []
    "browser" => null
    "displayArchiveStructs" => true
    "relatedEdition" => WP_Post {#4178
      +ID: 13224
      +post_author: "234"
      +post_date: "2023-11-23 16:53:44"
      +post_date_gmt: "2023-11-23 16:53:44"
      +post_content: """
        <!-- wp:group {"layout":{"type":"constrained"}} -->\n
        <div class="wp-block-group"><!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>PAW 2023 was the 7<sup>th</sup> edition of the PAW and by far the biggest, most impressive and most attended one since its inception, establishing the PAW as the most important arbitration event worldwide.</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>The 2023 edition enjoyed the support of 95 paying and 57 non-paying partners from around the world and featured no less than 143 events in five days! The events showcased a wealth of fascinating topics on international arbitration and world class speakers, and attracted a significant number of participants from around the globe, reaching 26,000 registrations during the week!&nbsp;</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>In line with its commitments, PAW 2023 kicked off with a keynote speech delivered by Dr. Yas Banifatemi on the issue of diversity in international arbitration and the Opening cocktail gathered over 1,000 participants (achieving an impressive record of 450 champagne bottles).</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>2023 also marked the launch of PAW’s new cutting-edge website, which transformed the experience for partners and participants alike and contributed significantly to the fantastic success of this edition.</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p>As co-Presidents of PAW 2023, we could not be prouder of what the PAW Board achieved in 2023!</p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph -->\n
        \n
        <!-- wp:paragraph -->\n
        <p><strong>Marily Paralika &amp; Raphaël Kaminsky</strong></p>\n
        <!-- /wp:paragraph --></div>\n
        <!-- /wp:group -->
        """
      +post_title: "2023"
      +post_excerpt: ""
      +post_status: "publish"
      +comment_status: "closed"
      +ping_status: "closed"
      +post_password: ""
      +post_name: "2023"
      +to_ping: ""
      +pinged: ""
      +post_modified: "2025-11-18 01:05:26"
      +post_modified_gmt: "2025-11-18 01:05:26"
      +post_content_filtered: ""
      +post_parent: 0
      +guid: "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/?post_type=edition&#038;p=13224"
      +menu_order: 0
      +post_type: "edition"
      +post_mime_type: ""
      +comment_count: "0"
      +filter: "raw"
      +"isCurrent": ""
      +"num": "2023"
      +"dateOpeningRegister": ""
      +"datePawEventRegister": ""
      +"dateStart": "2023-03-27"
      +"dateEnd": "2023-03-31"
      +"committeeImage": "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/vivaldi_n7rjva42qg.png"
      +"committeeDescription": "<p>From left to right : <strong>Dimana Diawara</strong> (Vice-president) ; <strong>Elsa PAPAREMBORDE</strong> (Vice-president) ; <strong>Claire PAULY</strong> (Vice-president) ; <strong>Marily PARALIKA</strong> (Co-President) ; <strong>Raphaël KAMINSKY</strong> (Co-President) ; <strong>Ioana KNOLL-TUDOR</strong> (Secretary General) ; <strong>Sabrina AÏNOUZ</strong> (Vice-President) ; <strong>Vanessa THIEFFRY</strong> (Treasurer) ; <strong>Benjamin SIINO</strong> (Vice-President)</p>"
      +"emailHeader": ""
      +"stats": {#4177
        +"eventsCount": "143"
        +"partnersCount": "152"
        +"participantsCount": "4500"
        +"registrationsCount": "22500"
        +"satisfaction": ""
      }
    }
    "edition_dates" => "23 - 27 March 2026"
    "static_pages" => array:9 [
      "middle_office" => "89"
      "digital_library" => "13219"
      "legal_notice" => "955"
      "privacy_statement" => "12766"
      "contact_us" => "95"
      "sign_in" => "424"
      "visitor_register" => "40592"
      "partner_register" => "28"
      "maintenance" => "40491"
    ]
    "event" => WP_Post {#4183
      +ID: 3408
      +post_author: "226"
      +post_date: "2023-03-27 11:39:05"
      +post_date_gmt: "2023-03-27 11:39:05"
      +post_content: """
        Dispositive motions, common practice in the United States, are gaining traction in the wider international arbitration community, making their way into several different global institutional rules. They are, however, less commonly used in civil law jurisdictions.\r\n
        \r\n
        Summary or dispositive proceedings are often promoted as tools to accelerate the resolution of a claim, promote efficiency, and conserve judicial resources. Despite these goals, do they live up to their extolled virtues in practice?\r\n
        \r\n
        Join Reed Smith global presenters and our star-studded panel of guest speakers gathered from near and far for a lively discussion exploring the value and efficiency of dispositive motions – covering the good, the bad, and the ugly – and looking at example case studies that may or may not benefit from dispositive motions. The discussion will also examine the ongoing debate on whether dispositive motions could violate the New York Convention’s presentment clause.\r\n
        \r\n
        Guest speakers:\r\n
        \r\n
        -          Patrick Baeten (Chief Legal Officer M&amp;A – Engie)\r\n
        -          Stefan Brocker (Partner, Mannheimer Swartling)\r\n
        -          Felix Dasser (President of the Swiss Arbitration Association)\r\n
        -          Harriet O'Neill (Retired Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of Texas)\r\n
        -          Edna Sussman (Arbitrator, Mediator)\r\n
        \r\n
        Reed Smith presenters:\r\n
        \r\n
        -          Peter Rosher - Paris, Global Chair of International Arbitration\r\n
        -          Antonia Birt - Dubai, Partner\r\n
        -          Matthew Townsend - Hong Kong, Partner\r\n
        -          Daniel Ávila II - Houston, Associate
        """
      +post_title: "Summary Dispositions in International Arbitration – an important tool or just going through the (dispositive) motions?"
      +post_excerpt: ""
      +post_status: "publish"
      +comment_status: "closed"
      +ping_status: "closed"
      +post_password: ""
      +post_name: "summary-dispositions-in-international-arbitration-an-important-tool-or-just-going-through-the-dispositive-motions"
      +to_ping: ""
      +pinged: ""
      +post_modified: "2023-03-27 11:39:05"
      +post_modified_gmt: "2023-03-27 11:39:05"
      +post_content_filtered: ""
      +post_parent: 0
      +guid: "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/summary-dispositions-in-international-arbitration-an-important-tool-or-just-going-through-the-dispositive-motions/"
      +menu_order: 0
      +post_type: "event"
      +post_mime_type: ""
      +comment_count: "0"
      +filter: "raw"
      +"review": ""
      +"state": "published"
      +"themes": array:2 [
        0 => WP_Term {#4182
          +term_id: 27
          +name: "Commercial arbitration"
          +slug: "commercial-arbitration"
          +term_group: 0
          +term_taxonomy_id: 27
          +taxonomy: "theme"
          +description: ""
          +parent: 0
          +count: 411
          +filter: "raw"
        }
        1 => WP_Term {#4181
          +term_id: 26
          +name: "Investment arbitration"
          +slug: "investment-arbitration"
          +term_group: 0
          +term_taxonomy_id: 26
          +taxonomy: "theme"
          +description: ""
          +parent: 0
          +count: 234
          +filter: "raw"
        }
      ]
      +"themeIDs": array:2 [
        0 => 27
        1 => 26
      ]
      +"regions": []
      +"regionIDs": []
      +"partnerID": "605"
      +"type": "by_request"
      +"category": "academic"
      +"format": "hybrid"
      +"paw_networking": ""
      +"coHosts": []
      +"date": "2023-03-27"
      +"startingTimeSlot": ""
      +"startTime": "14:30"
      +"endTime": "16:30"
      +"dateOpeningRegister": ""
      +"dateLimitRegister": "2023-03-27"
      +"showDateOpeningRegister": false
      +"isOpenForRegistration": true
      +"typeStart": "afternoon"
      +"edition": "13224"
      +"isCurrent": false
      +"registrationType": "paw"
      +"externalRegistrationLink": ""
      +"ticketsNumber": "79"
      +"onlineConfLink": "https://reedsmith.zoom.us/j/98717942226?pwd=ci96TnBkLzllbjBJTjJmUlRKOW5BZz09"
      +"hasWaitingList": false
      +"replay": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xh4Td4vxZto"
      +"photos": array:4 [
        0 => "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-d.jpg"
        1 => "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-b.jpg"
        2 => "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-f.jpg"
        3 => "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/gravity_forms/19-4a7412615f3e37f0bfe5f293549145d2/2023/06/.paw-event-1-bb.jpg"
      ]
      +"publication": ""
      +"publication_description": ""
      +"address": {#4180
        +"street": "112 Av. Kléber"
        +"building": ""
        +"city": "Paris"
        +"postcode": "75116"
        +"information": ""
        +"gps": "48.8642909,2.2878794"
        +"maps_query": "112+Av.+Kléber,75116,Paris"
      }
      +"speakerHosts": array:4 [
        0 => "314"
        1 => "315"
        2 => "316"
        3 => "317"
      ]
      +"speakerGuests": array:5 [
        0 => "323"
        1 => "326"
        2 => "328"
        3 => "329"
        4 => "447"
      ]
      +"attendeeReminderLastSent": ""
      +"attendees": array:462 [
        338 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 338
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        346 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 346
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        350 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 350
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        282 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 282
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        361 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 361
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        362 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 362
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        372 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 372
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        384 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 384
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        389 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 389
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        393 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 393
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        399 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 399
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        408 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 408
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        154 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 154
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        421 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 421
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        422 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 422
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        431 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 431
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        432 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 432
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        437 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 437
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        443 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 443
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        462 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 462
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        474 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 474
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        246 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 246
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        492 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 492
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        516 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 516
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        523 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 523
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        461 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 461
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        549 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 549
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        558 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 558
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        559 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 559
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        563 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 563
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        458 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 458
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        584 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 584
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        601 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 601
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        612 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 612
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        622 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 622
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        629 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 629
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        666 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 666
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        667 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 667
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        684 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 684
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        694 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 694
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        709 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 709
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        719 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 719
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920154
        ]
        720 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 720
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        727 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 727
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        731 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 731
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        742 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 742
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679935422
        ]
        743 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 743
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        476 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 476
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920803
        ]
        507 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 507
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        793 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 793
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        801 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 801
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        802 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 802
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        438 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 438
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        498 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 498
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920327
        ]
        281 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 281
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        822 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 822
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        820 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 820
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        834 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 834
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679921836
        ]
        848 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 848
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        852 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 852
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920213
        ]
        853 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 853
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        404 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 404
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        871 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 871
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        555 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 555
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        922 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 922
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        923 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 923
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        914 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 914
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        915 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 915
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        937 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 937
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        954 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 954
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        966 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 966
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        987 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 987
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1006 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1006
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1018 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1018
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1022 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1022
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        240 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 240
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679918874
        ]
        405 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 405
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1055 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1055
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1068 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1068
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        319 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 319
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1078 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1078
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1103 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1103
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1109 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1109
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1113 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1113
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1089 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1089
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1160 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1160
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1161 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1161
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1165 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1165
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1167 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1167
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1194 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1194
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        888 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 888
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1213 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1213
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1220 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1220
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1230 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1230
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        383 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 383
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        450 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 450
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1260 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1260
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1264 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1264
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1243 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1243
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1285 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1285
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1288 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1288
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1292 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1292
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1106 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1106
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1130 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1130
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1316 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1316
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1040 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1040
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1335 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1335
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        284 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 284
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1353 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1353
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1361 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1361
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1367 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1367
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        712 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 712
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1372 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1372
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1376 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1376
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1387 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1387
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1180 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1180
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1395 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1395
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1364 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1364
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1420 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1420
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1427 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1427
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1433 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1433
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1437 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1437
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1441 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1441
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1444 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1444
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1458 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1458
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1181 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1181
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1487 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1487
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1500 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1500
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1499 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1499
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        769 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 769
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1521 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1521
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1346 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1346
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1347 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1347
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        561 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 561
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1545 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1545
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1551 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1551
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1538 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1538
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1462 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1462
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1573 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1573
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1323 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1323
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1578 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1578
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        908 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 908
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1595 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1595
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1606 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1606
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1615 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1615
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1631 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1631
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1636 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1636
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        753 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 753
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1168 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1168
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1443 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1443
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1753 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1753
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1758 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1758
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1806 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1806
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1874 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1874
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1817 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1817
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1923 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1923
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1043 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1043
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1946 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1946
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1093 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1093
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1534 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1534
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1377 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1377
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        349 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 349
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2013 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2013
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        531 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 531
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2075 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2075
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1604 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1604
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        449 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 449
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2086 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2086
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1974 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1974
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1365 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1365
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2138 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2138
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1037 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1037
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2153 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2153
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        577 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 577
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2176 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2176
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1720 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1720
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2224 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2224
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        313 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 313
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2226 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2226
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2101 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2101
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2279 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2279
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1262 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1262
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2151 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2151
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2303 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2303
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2306 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2306
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        445 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 445
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        999 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 999
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2349 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2349
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2352 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2352
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1091 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1091
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2368 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2368
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2370 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2370
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1283 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1283
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2338 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2338
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2076 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2076
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1209 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1209
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2421 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 2421
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920753
        ]
        538 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 538
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1349 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1349
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2444 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2444
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2454 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 2454
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920452
        ]
        2457 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 2457
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679919124
        ]
        2485 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2485
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1041 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1041
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2399 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2399
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2496 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2496
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2477 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 2477
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679919876
        ]
        340 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 340
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920424
        ]
        2510 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2510
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2136 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2136
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2502 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2502
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1116 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1116
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1925 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1925
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2553 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2553
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1918 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1918
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        226 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 226
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1238 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 1238
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920941
        ]
        2610 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2610
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1173 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1173
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1382 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1382
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        464 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 464
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2622 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2622
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2220 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2220
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2623 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2623
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2625 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2625
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2635 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2635
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2536 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2536
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2453 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2453
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2649 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2649
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2385 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2385
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2427 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2427
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2676 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2676
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2689 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2689
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1620 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1620
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        353 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 353
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2715 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2715
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2281 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2281
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2192 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 2192
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920397
        ]
        2731 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 2731
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920394
        ]
        2736 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2736
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2739 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2739
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2727 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2727
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2157 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 2157
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679919743
        ]
        2750 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2750
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1496 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1496
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2538 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 2538
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920578
        ]
        2752 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2752
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1531 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1531
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1722 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1722
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2788 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2788
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2266 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2266
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2789 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2789
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2790 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2790
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1188 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1188
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1394 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1394
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2601 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2601
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2823 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2823
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2846 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2846
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        560 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 560
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1454 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1454
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2873 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2873
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2883 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2883
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2918 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2918
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1899 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 1899
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920301
        ]
        1804 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1804
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        429 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 429
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1476 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1476
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2528 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2528
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3025 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3025
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1950 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1950
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1044 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1044
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3136 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3136
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1272 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1272
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1567 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1567
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3194 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3194
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3233 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3233
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1328 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1328
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3250 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3250
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3254 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3254
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3181 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3181
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3298 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3298
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3321 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3321
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1819 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1819
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3370 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3370
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1577 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1577
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3410 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3410
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2920 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2920
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3460 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3460
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2658 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2658
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1125 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1125
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1483 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1483
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1734 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1734
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3310 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3310
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3198 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3198
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3314 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3314
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        332 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 332
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3634 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3634
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1075 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1075
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1959 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1959
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3646 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3646
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        317 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 317
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3730 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3730
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3749 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3749
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3742 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3742
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3752 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3752
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3162 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3162
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3804 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3804
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3815 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3815
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1423 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1423
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        244 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 244
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3629 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 3629
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679923356
        ]
        505 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 505
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3645 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3645
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3880 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3880
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3886 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3886
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3810 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3810
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2127 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2127
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3278 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3278
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3739 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3739
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3092 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3092
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3925 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3925
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3929 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3929
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2688 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2688
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2215 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2215
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2591 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2591
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3984 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3984
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1063 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1063
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4111 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4111
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4122 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4122
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4137 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4137
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4138 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4138
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4184 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4184
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4210 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4210
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4221 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4221
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4230 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4230
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3336 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3336
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3642 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3642
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3153 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3153
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4243 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4243
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2879 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2879
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4248 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4248
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2705 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2705
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4261 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4261
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4254 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4254
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        675 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 675
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        668 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 668
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4311 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4311
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3444 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3444
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4339 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4339
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2758 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2758
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4374 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4374
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4379 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4379
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4396 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4396
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4445 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4445
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2544 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2544
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4481 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4481
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3800 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3800
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4489 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4489
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2492 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2492
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2857 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2857
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4499 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4499
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4504 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4504
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3920 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3920
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2091 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2091
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3064 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3064
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2520 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2520
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4568 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4568
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4581 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4581
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1083 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1083
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4588 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4588
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1676 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 1676
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679918997
        ]
        4600 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4600
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        993 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 993
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4617 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4617
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4510 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4510
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4633 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4633
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        434 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 434
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4662 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4662
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        734 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 734
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3847 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3847
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4604 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4604
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2336 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2336
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4409 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4409
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        570 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 570
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4700 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4700
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4707 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4707
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4711 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4711
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4713 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4713
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4701 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4701
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4734 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4734
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4722 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4722
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4753 => array:4 [
          "userID" => 4753
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "date_scan" => 1679920668
        ]
        4766 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4766
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4765 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4765
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4764 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4764
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4768 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4768
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4503 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4503
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4691 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4691
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4516 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4516
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1853 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1853
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4805 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4805
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4817 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4817
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4822 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4822
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3029 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3029
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4809 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4809
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1506 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1506
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4847 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4847
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4860 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4860
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1791 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1791
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2275 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2275
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4896 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4896
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4903 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4903
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4904 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4904
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4914 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4914
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1314 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1314
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4927 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4927
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4951 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4951
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4975 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4975
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4986 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4986
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4990 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4990
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5006 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5006
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3306 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3306
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5061 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5061
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        590 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 590
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5082 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5082
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4702 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4702
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5083 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5083
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2307 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2307
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3679 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3679
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2513 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2513
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4417 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4417
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4756 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4756
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1687 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1687
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4596 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4596
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5157 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5157
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2329 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2329
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2662 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2662
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1571 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1571
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1304 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1304
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5184 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5184
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5199 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5199
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5207 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5207
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        4864 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 4864
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5223 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5223
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5224 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5224
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5251 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5251
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        2757 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 2757
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5282 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5282
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5283 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5283
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        947 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 947
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5149 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5149
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5294 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5294
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5307 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5307
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3605 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3605
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3218 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3218
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5312 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5312
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5215 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5215
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        1869 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 1869
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5339 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5339
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3435 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3435
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        3272 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 3272
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
        5352 => array:3 [
          "userID" => 5352
          "presence" => "online"
          "status" => "accepted"
        ]
      ]
      +"stats": {#4179
        +"total": "79"
        +"accepted": 462
        +"pending": 0
        +"declined": 0
        +"cancelled": 0
        +"waiting": 0
        +"in_person": 76
        +"online": 386
        +"checked_in": 0
        +"left": 3
      }
    }
    "realHostSpeakers" => array:4 [
      0 => 314
      1 => 315
      2 => 316
      3 => 317
    ]
    "userID" => "447"
    "user" => WP_User {#4596
      +data: {#4594
        +"ID": "447"
        +"user_login": "patrick.baeten@engie.com"
        +"user_pass": "$P$BW05C2WKyQtaWvVFrhSPc7U5tE3Nc2/"
        +"user_nicename": "patrick-baetenengie-com"
        +"user_email": "patrick.baeten@engie.com"
        +"user_url": ""
        +"user_registered": "2023-01-11 19:47:00"
        +"user_activation_key": ""
        +"user_status": "0"
        +"display_name": "patrick.baeten@engie.com"
        +"review": ""
        +"state": "published"
        +"first_name": "Patrick"
        +"last_name": "BAETEN"
        +"full_name": "Patrick BAETEN"
        +"civility": ""
        +"description": """
          Patrick Baeten graduated in law from the University of Ghent and holds an LLM in international law from the University of Louvain-la-Neuve. \r\n
          \r\n
          He joined ENGIE in 1996 after three years at the Brussels’ bar. Patrick held several senior positions at regional level (general counsel Europe 2006-2015, general counsel Brazil 2019-2021) and at corporate level (chief legal officer competition & regulation 2003-2006, chief legal officer global disputes 2016-2018). He now serves as ENGIE’s chief legal officer for mergers, acquisitions and investments.\r\n
          \r\n
          Patrick lectured European energy law at the University of Leuven. He is a member of  the Scientific Committee of the CEPINA, the Advisory Board of the Climate Change Arbitration Monitor, the ICC Commission on Arbitration and ADR, and has participated to several ICC task forces. He is a regular speaker at conferences, in particular on energy, climate change and litigation.\r\n
          Patrick is fluent in English, French and Dutch and has working knowledge of Portuguese.
          """
        +"citation": ""
        +"citationAuthor": ""
        +"company": "Engie"
        +"companyID": ""
        +"job": "Chief Legal Officer M&A"
        +"status": "1"
        +"phone": "+33176704000"
        +"country": ""
        +"city": ""
        +"twitter": ""
        +"linkedin": "https://www.linkedin.com/in/patrick-baeten-69719436/"
        +"default_paw_networking": ""
        +"avatar": "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/patrick-baeten-1065x1065_447.jpg"
        +"rang": ""
        +"activity": ""
        +"themes": ""
        +"companyName": "Engie"
        +"favorites": []
      }
      +ID: 447
      +caps: array:1 [
        "speaker" => true
      ]
      +cap_key: "wp_capabilities"
      +roles: array:1 [
        0 => "speaker"
      ]
      +allcaps: array:2 [
        "read" => true
        "speaker" => true
      ]
      +filter: null
      -site_id: 1
    }
    "realGuestSpeakers" => array:5 [
      0 => 323
      1 => 326
      2 => 328
      3 => 329
      4 => 447
    ]
    "partner" => WP_Post {#4645
      +ID: 605
      +post_author: "5985"
      +post_date: "2026-02-17 14:29:11"
      +post_date_gmt: "2026-02-17 14:29:11"
      +post_content: """
        Reed Smith is a dynamic international law firm dedicated to helping clients move their businesses forward. With an inclusive culture and innovative mindset, we deliver smarter, more creative legal services that drive better outcomes for our clients.\r\n
        \r\n
        Our deep industry knowledge, long-standing relationships and collaborative structure make us the go-to partner for complex disputes, transactions and regulatory matters.\r\n
        \r\n
        Reed Smith’s international arbitration practice is ranked in the elite GAR 30 2022, Global Arbitration Review’s list of the world’s top 30 leading international arbitration practices.\r\n
        \r\n
        Our clients, whether privately or publicly owned, benefit from the invaluable insights, in-depth knowledge, award-winning talent and cross-border collaboration of our global team of international arbitration lawyers, many embedded in our core industry practice areas.
        """
      +post_title: "Reed Smith"
      +post_excerpt: ""
      +post_status: "publish"
      +comment_status: "closed"
      +ping_status: "closed"
      +post_password: ""
      +post_name: "reed-smith"
      +to_ping: ""
      +pinged: ""
      +post_modified: "2026-02-26 13:14:00"
      +post_modified_gmt: "2026-02-26 13:14:00"
      +post_content_filtered: ""
      +post_parent: 0
      +guid: "https://parisarbitrationweek.ontest.net/?post_type=partner&#038;p=605"
      +menu_order: 0
      +post_type: "partner"
      +post_mime_type: ""
      +comment_count: "0"
      +filter: "raw"
      +"review": ""
      +"state": "online"
      +"paymentCustomer": ""
      +"paymentURL": ""
      +"paymentID": ""
      +"paymentStatus": "valid"
      +"paymentInvoiceNumber": ""
      +"paymentInvoiceDate": ""
      +"category": "law_firm"
      +"type": "paying_big"
      +"logos": array:1 [
        610 => "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/reed-smith_logo_paw.png"
      ]
      +"citation": ""
      +"citationAuthor": ""
      +"website": "https://www.reedsmith.com/en"
      +"linkedin": "https://www.linkedin.com/company/reed-smith-llp/"
      +"twiter": "https://twitter.com/reedsmithllp"
      +"contactEmail": "cfouchard@reedsmith.com"
      +"address": {#4646
        +"street1": "112 Avenue Kléber"
        +"street2": ""
        +"street": "112 Avenue Kléber "
        +"postcode": "75116"
        +"city": "Paris"
        +"country": "France"
        +"legal_entity": ""
        +"billing_street1": ""
        +"billing_street2": ""
        +"billing_street": " "
        +"billing_postcode": ""
        +"billing_city": ""
        +"billing_country": ""
      }
      +"masterUsers": array:1 [
        0 => "17207"
      ]
      +"speakerHosts": array:17 [
        0 => "314"
        1 => "315"
        2 => "316"
        3 => "1804"
        4 => "6329"
        5 => "6584"
        6 => "6932"
        7 => "1547"
        8 => "1506"
        9 => "9966"
        10 => "9967"
        11 => "9968"
        12 => "10929"
        13 => "15164"
        14 => "1571"
        15 => "13084"
        16 => "2122"
      ]
      +"speakerGuests": array:37 [
        0 => "323"
        1 => "326"
        2 => "328"
        3 => "329"
        4 => "447"
        5 => "4220"
        6 => "4849"
        7 => "1611"
        8 => "1495"
        9 => "4852"
        10 => "1792"
        11 => "1243"
        12 => "6922"
        13 => "7313"
        14 => "7314"
        15 => "6559"
        16 => "7309"
        17 => "3532"
        18 => "6538"
        19 => "1280"
        20 => "10017"
        21 => "10021"
        22 => "10344"
        23 => "10874"
        24 => "11133"
        25 => "3315"
        26 => "12172"
        27 => "5858"
        28 => "13789"
        29 => "1130"
        30 => "6003"
        31 => "929"
        32 => "12596"
        33 => "9632"
        34 => "16579"
        35 => "17237"
        36 => "18430"
      ]
      +"strategic": {#4647
        +"lastname": ""
        +"firstname": ""
        +"email": ""
        +"phone": ""
        +"job": ""
        +"civility": ""
      }
      +"otherContacts": array:7 [
        0 => array:5 [
          "lastname" => "Tetley"
          "firstname" => "Andrew"
          "event" => "Opening Cocktail"
          "email" => "atetley@reedsmith.com"
          "phone" => "+33176704057"
        ]
        1 => array:5 [
          "lastname" => "Tetley"
          "firstname" => "Andrew"
          "event" => "In-house Event"
          "email" => "ATetley@reedsmith.com"
          "phone" => "+33176704057"
        ]
        2 => array:5 [
          "lastname" => "Lopez"
          "firstname" => "Aurelie"
          "event" => "Closing Cocktail"
          "email" => "alopez@reedsmith.com"
          "phone" => "+33176704000"
        ]
        3 => array:5 [
          "lastname" => "Jacquot"
          "firstname" => "Diana"
          "event" => "Sustainability Event"
          "email" => "djacquot@reedsmith.com"
          "phone" => "+33176704074"
        ]
        4 => array:5 [
          "lastname" => "Winnington-ingram"
          "firstname" => "Lucy"
           …3
        ]
        5 => array:5 [ …5]
        6 => array:5 [ …5]
      ]
      +"editions": array:4 [
        0 => "40615"
        1 => "39376"
        2 => "13223"
        3 => "13224"
      ]
      +"currentEvents": array:2 [
        0 => 40885
        1 => 40960
      ]
    }
    "can_see_participants" => false
    "showAllParticipants" => false
    "isAccepted" => null
    "isPending" => null
    "isDeclined" => null
    "isWaiting" => null
    "status_class" => null
  ]
  "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
  "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
  "override" => "app"
  "display_sidebar" => false
  "notices" => []
  "browser" => null
  "displayArchiveStructs" => true
  "relatedEdition" => WP_Post {#4178}
  "edition_dates" => "23 - 27 March 2026"
  "static_pages" => array:9 [
    "middle_office" => "89"
    "digital_library" => "13219"
    "legal_notice" => "955"
    "privacy_statement" => "12766"
    "contact_us" => "95"
    "sign_in" => "424"
    "visitor_register" => "40592"
    "partner_register" => "28"
    "maintenance" => "40491"
  ]
  "event" => WP_Post {#4183}
  "realHostSpeakers" => array:4 [
    0 => 314
    1 => 315
    2 => 316
    3 => 317
  ]
  "userID" => "447"
  "user" => WP_User {#4596}
  "realGuestSpeakers" => array:5 [
    0 => 323
    1 => 326
    2 => 328
    3 => 329
    4 => 447
  ]
  "partner" => WP_Post {#4645}
  "can_see_participants" => false
  "showAllParticipants" => false
  "isAccepted" => null
  "isPending" => null
  "isDeclined" => null
  "isWaiting" => null
  "status_class" => null
]