Richard MARSHALL


Expert Witness
Concept Gap Ltd

Dr. Richard M. Marshall, PhD, is the Principal of Concept Gap and a seasoned technical expert witness with over 30 years of experience in software innovation and design.

A "battle-hardened" entrepreneur and former Gartner analyst, Richard has written hundreds of thousands of lines of code and numerous technical reports.

He specializes in communicating complex technical subjects for juries, judges, tribunals, and counsel. He has been instrumental in securing over $2 billion in compensation for his clients, notably serving as the lead technical expert in the record-breaking Appian vs. Pegasystems trade secret case. Beyond IP and trade secrets, Richard’s practice encompasses high-profile confidential matters involving complex data analysis and cybersecurity breaches, where he deconstructs "black-box" systems to provide forensic clarity.

When not navigating forensic code reviews or voir-dire challenges, he maintains his mental and physical agility by practicing Parkour.

Richard MARSHALL

PAW Events

Current edition

Don't miss anything

 array:19 [
  "__path" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache/c84ebf1432a129894c6a5ed11ec848552cf558ba.php"
  "__data" => array:17 [
    "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419
      #engines: Illuminate\View\Engines\EngineResolver {#2411
        #resolvers: array:3 [
          "file" => Closure() {#2412 …2}
          "php" => Closure() {#2413 …2}
          "blade" => Closure() {#2414 …2}
        ]
        #resolved: array:1 [
          "blade" => Illuminate\View\Engines\CompilerEngine {#4213 …3}
        ]
      }
      #finder: Illuminate\View\FileViewFinder {#2415
        #files: Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
        #paths: array:1 [
          0 => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views"
        ]
        #views: array:12 [
          "author" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/author.blade.php"
          "partials.expanding-avatar" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/expanding-avatar.blade.php"
          "partials.item-event" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/item-event.blade.php"
          "partials.event-format" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/event-format.blade.php"
          "blocks.calendar-cta-banner" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/blocks/calendar-cta-banner.blade.php"
          "layouts.app" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/layouts/app.blade.php"
          "structs.head" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/head.blade.php"
          "structs.header" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/header.blade.php"
          "partials.notices" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/notices.blade.php"
          "partials.breadcrumbs" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/breadcrumbs.blade.php"
          "structs.footer" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/structs/footer.blade.php"
          "partials.nav-social" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/src/themes/paw/resources/views/partials/nav-social.blade.php"
        ]
        #hints: []
        #extensions: array:4 [
          0 => "blade.php"
          1 => "php"
          2 => "css"
          3 => "html"
        ]
      }
      #events: Illuminate\Events\Dispatcher {#2417
        #container: Illuminate\Container\Container {#2418
          #resolved: []
          #bindings: []
          #methodBindings: []
          #instances: []
          #scopedInstances: []
          #aliases: []
          #abstractAliases: []
          #extenders: []
          #tags: []
          #buildStack: []
          #with: []
          +contextual: []
          #reboundCallbacks: []
          #globalBeforeResolvingCallbacks: []
          #globalResolvingCallbacks: []
          #globalAfterResolvingCallbacks: []
          #beforeResolvingCallbacks: []
          #resolvingCallbacks: []
          #afterResolvingCallbacks: []
        }
        #listeners: []
        #wildcards: []
        #wildcardsCache: array:24 [
          "creating: author" => []
          "composing: author" => []
          "creating: partials.expanding-avatar" => []
          "composing: partials.expanding-avatar" => []
          "creating: partials.item-event" => []
          "composing: partials.item-event" => []
          "creating: partials.event-format" => []
          "composing: partials.event-format" => []
          "creating: blocks.calendar-cta-banner" => []
          "composing: blocks.calendar-cta-banner" => []
          "creating: layouts.app" => []
          "composing: layouts.app" => []
          "creating: structs.head" => []
          "composing: structs.head" => []
          "creating: structs.header" => []
          "composing: structs.header" => []
          "creating: partials.notices" => []
          "composing: partials.notices" => []
          "creating: partials.breadcrumbs" => []
          "composing: partials.breadcrumbs" => []
          "creating: structs.footer" => []
          "composing: structs.footer" => []
          "creating: partials.nav-social" => []
          "composing: partials.nav-social" => []
        ]
        #queueResolver: null
      }
      #container: Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401
        #resolved: array:7 [
          "view.engine.resolver" => true
          "files" => true
          "config" => true
          "view.finder" => true
          "events" => true
          "view" => true
          "blade.compiler" => true
        ]
        #bindings: array:7 [
          "files" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2403 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "events" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2404 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "config" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2405 …3}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2407 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view.finder" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2408 …2}
            "shared" => false
          ]
          "blade.compiler" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure($app) {#2409 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
          "view.engine.resolver" => array:2 [
            "concrete" => Closure() {#2410 …2}
            "shared" => true
          ]
        ]
        #methodBindings: []
        #instances: array:6 [
          "view.engine.resolver" => Illuminate\View\Engines\EngineResolver {#2411}
          "files" => Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
          "config" => array:2 [
            "view.paths" => array:1 [ …1]
            "view.compiled" => "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache"
          ]
          "events" => Illuminate\Events\Dispatcher {#2417}
          "view" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
          "blade.compiler" => Illuminate\View\Compilers\BladeCompiler {#2420
            #files: Illuminate\Filesystem\Filesystem {#2416}
            #cachePath: "/var/www/vhosts/parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/httpdocs/wp/wp-content/uploads/cache"
            #extensions: []
            #customDirectives: array:4 [ …4]
            #conditions: []
            #precompilers: []
            #path: null
            #compilers: array:3 [ …3]
            #rawTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #contentTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #escapedTags: array:2 [ …2]
            #echoFormat: "e(%s)"
            #footer: []
            #rawBlocks: []
            #classComponentAliases: array:1 [ …1]
            #classComponentNamespaces: []
            #compilesComponentTags: true
            #firstCaseInSwitch: true
            #echoHandlers: []
            -encodingOptions: 15
            #lastSection: null
            #forElseCounter: 0
          }
        ]
        #scopedInstances: []
        #aliases: []
        #abstractAliases: []
        #extenders: []
        #tags: []
        #buildStack: []
        #with: []
        +contextual: []
        #reboundCallbacks: []
        #globalBeforeResolvingCallbacks: []
        #globalResolvingCallbacks: []
        #globalAfterResolvingCallbacks: []
        #beforeResolvingCallbacks: []
        #resolvingCallbacks: []
        #afterResolvingCallbacks: []
      }
      #shared: array:2 [
        "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
        "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
      ]
      #extensions: array:4 [
        "blade.php" => "blade"
        "php" => "php"
        "css" => "file"
        "html" => "file"
      ]
      #composers: []
      #renderCount: 3
      #renderedOnce: []
      #componentStack: []
      #componentData: []
      #currentComponentData: []
      #slots: []
      #slotStack: []
      #sections: array:1 [
        "content" => """
              <div class="wrapper">\n
                  <h1>Richard MARSHALL</h1>\n
                  <hr />\n
                  <div class="infos">\n
                      <div class="job">\n
                          Expert Witness\n
                      </div>\n
                                      <div class="company">\n
                              Concept Gap Ltd\n
                          </div>\n
                              </div>\n
                  <hr />\n
                  \n
                  <div class="author-columns">\n
                      <div class="column-left">\n
                          <p>Dr. Richard M. Marshall, PhD, is the Principal of Concept Gap and a seasoned technical expert witness with over 30 years of experience in software innovation and design. </p>\n
          <p>A "battle-hardened" entrepreneur and former Gartner analyst, Richard has written hundreds of thousands of lines of code and numerous technical reports. </p>\n
          <p>He specializes in communicating complex technical subjects for juries, judges, tribunals, and counsel. He has been instrumental in securing over $2 billion in compensation for his clients, notably serving as the lead technical expert in the record-breaking Appian vs. Pegasystems trade secret case. Beyond IP and trade secrets, Richard’s practice encompasses high-profile confidential matters involving complex data analysis and cybersecurity breaches, where he deconstructs "black-box" systems to provide forensic clarity. </p>\n
          <p>When not navigating forensic code reviews or voir-dire challenges, he maintains his mental and physical agility by practicing Parkour.</p>\n
          \n
                                              <div class="socials">\n
                                                              <a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/rmmarshall/" class="mr-3" target="_blank">\n
                                          <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="37.63" height="37.63" viewBox="0 0 37.63 37.63">\n
            <g transform="translate(-249 -866.717)">\n
              <path d="M37.63,18.879A18.815,18.815,0,1,1,18.815.064,18.815,18.815,0,0,1,37.63,18.879" transform="translate(249 866.653)" fill="#7593FF"/>\n
              <rect width="3.03" height="9.111" transform="translate(261.224 881.1)" fill="#fff"/>\n
              <path d="M13.739,13.2h-.02a1.579,1.579,0,1,1,.04-3.15,1.58,1.58,0,1,1-.02,3.15" transform="translate(249 866.653)" fill="#fff"/>\n
              <path d="M26.176,23.558H23.147V18.684c0-1.225-.438-2.062-1.535-2.062a1.661,1.661,0,0,0-1.554,1.109,2.067,2.067,0,0,0-.1.739v5.088H16.93s.039-8.257,0-9.111h3.028v1.29a3.007,3.007,0,0,1,2.73-1.5c1.993,0,3.488,1.3,3.488,4.1Z" transform="translate(249 866.653)" fill="#fff"/>\n
            </g>\n
          </svg>\n
                                      </a> \n
                                                                              </div>\n
                                      </div>\n
                      <div class="column-right ">\n
                                              <div class="expanding-avatar">\n
              <div class="expanding-avatar-container">\n
                  <figure class="expanding-avatar-figure">\n
          \n
                      <img src="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/suite-and-tie-large-1060x1060_16965.jpg" alt="Richard MARSHALL"/>\n
                      \n
                      <div class="expanding-avatar-corner expanding-avatar-corner--top-left">\n
                          <svg width="50" height="50" viewBox="0 0 50 50" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">\n
                              <path d="M1.04061 49.4195C0.466973 49.4195 0.00195308 48.9544 0.00195312 48.3808L0.00195697 2.7194C0.00195705 1.794 1.12074 1.3306 1.77506 1.9849L47.4365 47.6464C48.0908 48.3007 47.6274 49.4195 46.702 49.4195H1.04061Z" fill="#0128FF"/>\n
                          </svg>\n
                      </div>\n
                      <div class="expanding-avatar-corner expanding-avatar-corner--top-right">\n
                          <svg width="50" height="50" viewBox="0 0 50 50" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">\n
                              <path d="M48.3779 0C48.9516 0 49.4166 0.465031 49.4166 1.03867L49.4166 46.7001C49.4166 47.6254 48.2978 48.0888 47.6435 47.4345L1.9821 1.7731C1.3278 1.11878 1.7912 0 2.7165 0L48.3779 0Z" fill="#0128FF"/>\n
                          </svg>\n
                      </div>\n
                      <div class="expanding-avatar-corner expanding-avatar-corner--bottom-right">\n
                          <svg width="50" height="50" viewBox="0 0 50 50" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">\n
                              <path d="M49.4185 48.3808C49.4185 48.9544 48.9535 49.4194 48.3799 49.4194H2.7185C1.7931 49.4194 1.3297 48.3007 1.984 47.6463L47.6454 1.9849C48.2997 1.3306 49.4185 1.794 49.4185 2.7194V48.3808Z" fill="#0128FF"/>\n
                          </svg>\n
                      </div>\n
                      <div class="expanding-avatar-corner expanding-avatar-corner--bottom-left">\n
                          <svg width="50" height="50" viewBox="0 0 50 50" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">\n
                              <path d="M0 1.03865C0 0.46502 0.465027 0 1.03866 0L46.7001 0C47.6254 0 48.0888 1.11879 47.4345 1.7731L1.7731 47.4345C1.11878 48.0888 0 47.6254 0 46.7001L0 1.03865Z" fill="#0128FF"/>\n
                          </svg>\n
                      </div>\n
                  </figure>\n
              </div>\n
          </div>                            </div>\n
                  </div>\n
                      </div>\n
               \n
          \n
                          <div class="wrapper user-events">\n
                      <h3>PAW Events</h3>\n
          \n
                                      <section class="events period-current">\n
                              <h4>Current edition</h4>\n
                                                                              <div \n
              class="item event "\n
              data-id="40854"\n
              data-partner="[&quot;3222&quot;]"\n
              data-speakers="[&quot;15312&quot;,&quot;16883&quot;,&quot;1079&quot;,&quot;16965&quot;]"\n
              data-themes="[31]"\n
              data-regions="[33]"\n
              data-format="in_person"\n
              data-schedule="morning"\n
              data-category="academic"\n
              data-date="2026-03-24"\n
              data-hours="08:30 - 10:30"\n
              data-video=""\n
              data-pictures=""\n
              data-publication=""\n
                      data-geoloc="48.8712104,2.3342243"\n
              >   <div class="inside" data-id="40854">\n
                  <div class="event-date">\n
                      <span class="day">\n
                                              Tue. <b>24</b>\n
                              Mar.\n
                                      </span>\n
                                      <span class="year">2026</span>\n
                              </div>\n
                  <div class="event-details">\n
                      <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/bird-bird-aarpi-2026-40854/" class="event-title">\n
                          When Code Becomes Evidence: Proving and Testing AI and Tech Claims in Arbitration\n
                      </a>\n
                      <div class="event-partners">\n
                          <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/partner/bird-bird-aarpi/" class="partner">Bird &amp; Bird AARPI</a>\n
                                      </div>\n
                                      <div class="event-themes">\n
                                                                                  <span class="theme">#Technology</span>\n
                                                                                                                              <span class="region">#Europe</span>\n
                                                                      </div>\n
                                          </div>\n
                  <div class="event-metas">\n
                      \n
                  \n
                                      <div class="event-format">\n
              <div class="term">\n
                  <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="15.036" height="7.786" viewBox="0 0 15.036 7.786">\r\n
            <path d="M7.708,7.328a.269.269,0,0,1,0,.38L.459,14.957A.269.269,0,0,1,0,14.767V.269A.269.269,0,0,1,.459.079Z" transform="translate(15.036) rotate(90)" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
          </svg>\r\n
          \n
                  IN PERSON\n
              </div>\n
          </div>\n
                      \n
                              </div>\n
                  \n
                                              <div class="event-ressources">\n
                                                      <span class="closed">CLOSED</span>\n
                                              </div>\n
                                  </div>\n
                  \n
              \n
                      <div class="map-det is-hidden">\n
                      <div class="date">\n
                          <div class="day">\n
                              Tuesday <b>24</b> March 2026\n
                          </div>\n
                          <div class="hours my-3">\n
                              08:30 - 10:30\n
                          </div>\n
                      </div>\n
                      <div class="title">When Code Becomes Evidence: Proving and Testing AI and Tech Claims in Arbitration</div>\n
                      <div class="my-3">\n
                          <div class="partner">Bird &amp; Bird AARPI</div>\n
                                      </div>\n
                      <div class="is-flex mb-3">\n
                          <span class="is-flex mr-5">\n
                              <div class="event-format">\n
              <div class="term">\n
                  <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="15.036" height="7.786" viewBox="0 0 15.036 7.786">\r\n
            <path d="M7.708,7.328a.269.269,0,0,1,0,.38L.459,14.957A.269.269,0,0,1,0,14.767V.269A.269.269,0,0,1,.459.079Z" transform="translate(15.036) rotate(90)" fill="currentColor"/>\r\n
          </svg>\r\n
          \n
                  IN PERSON\n
              </div>\n
          </div>\n
                          </span>\n
          \n
                                      </div>\n
                                      <div class="event-address">\n
                              <span>\n
                                  2 rue de la Chaussée d&#039;Antin\n
                                  75009\n
                                  Paris\n
                              </span>\n
                              <a href="https://www.google.com/maps/search/?api=1&query=2+rue+de+la+Chaussée+d&#039;Antin,75009,Paris" target="_blank" class="address-link button is-style-secondary mt-2">\n
                                  <span>How to get there</span>\n
                              </a>\n
                          </div>\n
                                  <a href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/bird-bird-aarpi-2026-40854/" class="button is-style-primary mt-5">\n
                          <span>Sign up\n
                              <i class="paw-icon-arrow"></i>\n
                          </span>\n
                      </a>\n
                  </div>\n
              \n
          \n
          </div>                                    </section>\n
                      \n
                      \n
                  </div>\n
                          \n
          \n
                  \n
                  <div class="wrapper">\n
                      <div class="wp-block-magina-calendar-cta-banner">\n
              <div class="calendar-cta-banner aligncompact">\n
                  <i class="icon-blue-light">\n
                      <svg width="98" height="98" viewBox="0 0 98 98" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">\n
          <path d="M95.4912 50.3797C96.3741 50.3797 97.0898 51.0955 97.0898 51.9784L97.0898 93.466C97.0898 94.8903 95.3678 95.6036 94.3607 94.5965L52.8731 53.1088C51.866 52.1017 52.5793 50.3797 54.0035 50.3797L95.4912 50.3797Z" fill="currentColor"/>\n
          <path d="M95.4912 0.237034C96.3741 0.237034 97.0898 0.952781 97.0898 1.8357L97.0898 43.3233C97.0898 44.7476 95.3678 45.4609 94.3607 44.4538L52.8731 2.96613C51.866 1.95902 52.5793 0.237031 54.0035 0.237032L95.4912 0.237034Z" fill="currentColor"/>\n
          <path d="M45.3476 -2.62386e-05C46.2305 -2.6179e-05 46.9463 0.715721 46.9463 1.59864L46.9463 43.0863C46.9463 44.5105 45.2243 45.2238 44.2172 44.2167L2.72956 2.72907C1.72246 1.72196 2.43573 -2.91323e-05 3.85999 -2.90363e-05L45.3476 -2.62386e-05Z" fill="currentColor"/>\n
          <path d="M45.3476 50.1426C46.2305 50.1426 46.9463 50.8583 46.9463 51.7412L46.9463 93.2289C46.9463 94.6531 45.2243 95.3664 44.2172 94.3593L2.72956 52.8716C1.72246 51.8645 2.43573 50.1425 3.85999 50.1425L45.3476 50.1426Z" fill="currentColor"/>\n
          </svg>\n
                  </i>\n
                  <div class="calendar-cta-content">\n
                      <div class="calendar-cta-heading">\n
                          <h3 class="is-style-h2">\n
                              Don't miss anything\n
                          </h3>\n
                      </div>\n
                      <div class="calendar-cta">\n
                          <a class="button is-style-primary-white" href="https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">\n
                              <span>See full calendar\n
                                  <i class="paw-icon-arrow"></i>\n
                              </span>\n
                          </a>\n
                      </div>\n
                  </div>\n
                  <i class="icon-blue">\n
                      <svg width="101" height="101" viewBox="0 0 101 101" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">\n
          <path d="M99.6526 49.1526C100.397 49.8968 100.397 51.1033 99.6526 51.8474L51.8474 99.6526C51.1032 100.397 49.8967 100.397 49.1526 99.6526L1.34739 51.8474C0.603248 51.1032 0.603249 49.8968 1.34739 49.1526L49.1526 1.34739C49.8968 0.603248 51.1033 0.603248 51.8474 1.34739L99.6526 49.1526Z" fill="currentColor"/>\n
          </svg>\n
                  </i>\n
              </div>\n
          </div>        </div>\n
              \n
          """
      ]
      #sectionStack: []
      #loopsStack: []
      #pushes: []
      #prepends: []
      #pushStack: []
      #translationReplacements: []
    }
    "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
    "override" => "app"
    "display_sidebar" => false
    "notices" => []
    "browser" => null
    "displayArchiveStructs" => false
    "relatedEdition" => WP_Post {#4171
      +ID: 40615
      +post_author: "234"
      +post_date: "2025-11-17 10:14:18"
      +post_date_gmt: "2025-11-17 10:14:18"
      +post_content: ""
      +post_title: "2026"
      +post_excerpt: ""
      +post_status: "publish"
      +comment_status: "closed"
      +ping_status: "closed"
      +post_password: ""
      +post_name: "2026"
      +to_ping: ""
      +pinged: ""
      +post_modified: "2026-02-12 11:08:32"
      +post_modified_gmt: "2026-02-12 11:08:32"
      +post_content_filtered: ""
      +post_parent: 0
      +guid: "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/?post_type=edition&#038;p=40615"
      +menu_order: 0
      +post_type: "edition"
      +post_mime_type: ""
      +comment_count: "0"
      +filter: "raw"
      +"isCurrent": "on"
      +"num": "2026"
      +"dateOpeningRegister": "2026-01-05"
      +"datePawEventRegister": "2026-02-20"
      +"dateStart": "2026-03-23"
      +"dateEnd": "2026-03-27"
      +"committeeImage": ""
      +"committeeDescription": ""
      +"emailHeader": "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/header-paw2026-v2.png"
      +"stats": {#4170
        +"eventsCount": ""
        +"partnersCount": ""
        +"participantsCount": ""
        +"registrationsCount": ""
        +"satisfaction": ""
      }
    }
    "edition_dates" => "23 - 27 March 2026"
    "static_pages" => array:9 [
      "middle_office" => "89"
      "digital_library" => "13219"
      "legal_notice" => "955"
      "privacy_statement" => "12766"
      "contact_us" => "95"
      "sign_in" => "424"
      "visitor_register" => "40592"
      "partner_register" => "28"
      "maintenance" => "40491"
    ]
    "user" => WP_User {#4166
      +data: {#4167
        +"ID": "16965"
        +"user_login": "richard.marshall@conceptgap.com"
        +"user_pass": "$wp$2y$10$br.i4/VA2h7kLPGovqzRG.lrGzT4CRXLK4iJoWDjS7L2ycdD/FLg2"
        +"user_nicename": "richard-marshall-16965"
        +"user_email": "richard.marshall@conceptgap.com"
        +"user_url": ""
        +"user_registered": "2026-02-18 16:56:03"
        +"user_activation_key": ""
        +"user_status": "0"
        +"display_name": "Richard Marshall"
        +"review": ""
        +"state": "published"
        +"first_name": "Richard"
        +"last_name": "MARSHALL"
        +"full_name": "Richard MARSHALL"
        +"civility": "Dr"
        +"description": """
          Dr. Richard M. Marshall, PhD, is the Principal of Concept Gap and a seasoned technical expert witness with over 30 years of experience in software innovation and design. \r\n
          \r\n
          A "battle-hardened" entrepreneur and former Gartner analyst, Richard has written hundreds of thousands of lines of code and numerous technical reports. \r\n
          \r\n
          He specializes in communicating complex technical subjects for juries, judges, tribunals, and counsel. He has been instrumental in securing over $2 billion in compensation for his clients, notably serving as the lead technical expert in the record-breaking Appian vs. Pegasystems trade secret case. Beyond IP and trade secrets, Richard’s practice encompasses high-profile confidential matters involving complex data analysis and cybersecurity breaches, where he deconstructs "black-box" systems to provide forensic clarity. \r\n
          \r\n
          When not navigating forensic code reviews or voir-dire challenges, he maintains his mental and physical agility by practicing Parkour.
          """
        +"citation": ""
        +"citationAuthor": ""
        +"company": "Concept Gap Ltd"
        +"companyID": "other"
        +"job": "Expert Witness"
        +"status": "1"
        +"phone": "+447785394458"
        +"country": "United Kingdom"
        +"city": ""
        +"twitter": ""
        +"linkedin": "https://www.linkedin.com/in/rmmarshall/"
        +"default_paw_networking": "1"
        +"avatar": "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/suite-and-tie-large-1060x1060_16965.jpg"
        +"rang": ""
        +"activity": "expert_firm"
        +"themes": array:1 [
          0 => "technology"
        ]
        +"companyName": "Concept Gap Ltd"
        +"favorites": []
      }
      +ID: 16965
      +caps: array:1 [
        "speaker" => true
      ]
      +cap_key: "wp_capabilities"
      +roles: array:1 [
        0 => "speaker"
      ]
      +allcaps: array:2 [
        "read" => true
        "speaker" => true
      ]
      +filter: null
      -site_id: 1
    }
    "currentEvents" => array:1 [
      0 => 40854
    ]
    "previousEvents" => []
    "__currentLoopData" => array:1 [
      0 => 40854
    ]
    "loop" => null
    "eventID" => 40854
    "event" => WP_Post {#4579
      +ID: 40854
      +post_author: "266"
      +post_date: "2026-03-10 13:53:00"
      +post_date_gmt: "2026-03-10 13:53:00"
      +post_content: """
        When disputes turn on source code, data architecture or algorithmic behaviour, traditional arbitral frameworks are put under pressure. How do tribunals meaningfully assess highly technical, dynamic and sometimes opaque digital evidence? How should arbitration adapt when the key exhibit is not a document, but a software repository?\r\n
        \r\n
        This Bird &amp; Bird panel will explore how international arbitration can be calibrated for technology-driven disputes in which code itself becomes central evidence. From the choice of an arbitral institution and seat, to the intervention of experts and organisation of the procedure, the discussion will examine the structural decisions that shape the quality and enforceability of awards in tech cases.\r\n
        \r\n
        Bringing together the perspectives of leading arbitrators, experts and counsel, this panel will address practical challenges faced by clients and arbitration practitioners alike, and explore a way forward for thoughtfully tailoring arbitral procedure to ensure it remains effective and fit for purpose in technology-driven disputes.\r\n
        \r\n
        This session will be of particular interest to in-house counsel in technology-intensive sectors, arbitrators, arbitration practitioners and experts regularly involved in disputes where software, data and algorithms are not background context, but the core of the case.
        """
      +post_title: "When Code Becomes Evidence: Proving and Testing AI and Tech Claims in Arbitration"
      +post_excerpt: ""
      +post_status: "publish"
      +comment_status: "closed"
      +ping_status: "closed"
      +post_password: ""
      +post_name: "bird-bird-aarpi-2026-40854"
      +to_ping: ""
      +pinged: ""
      +post_modified: "2026-03-10 13:53:00"
      +post_modified_gmt: "2026-03-10 13:53:00"
      +post_content_filtered: ""
      +post_parent: 0
      +guid: "https://parisarbitrationweek.preprod.online/event/when-code-becomes-evidence-proving-and-testing-ai-and-tech-claims-in-arbitration/"
      +menu_order: 0
      +post_type: "event"
      +post_mime_type: ""
      +comment_count: "0"
      +filter: "raw"
      +"review": ""
      +"state": "closed"
      +"themes": array:1 [
        0 => WP_Term {#4581
          +term_id: 31
          +name: "Technology"
          +slug: "technology"
          +term_group: 0
          +term_taxonomy_id: 31
          +taxonomy: "theme"
          +description: ""
          +parent: 0
          +count: 34
          +filter: "raw"
        }
      ]
      +"themeIDs": array:1 [
        0 => 31
      ]
      +"regions": array:1 [
        0 => WP_Term {#4576
          +term_id: 33
          +name: "Europe"
          +slug: "europe"
          +term_group: 0
          +term_taxonomy_id: 33
          +taxonomy: "region"
          +description: ""
          +parent: 0
          +count: 275
          +filter: "raw"
        }
      ]
      +"regionIDs": array:1 [
        0 => 33
      ]
      +"partnerID": "3222"
      +"type": "by_request"
      +"category": "academic"
      +"format": "in_person"
      +"paw_networking": ""
      +"coHosts": []
      +"date": "2026-03-24"
      +"startingTimeSlot": "37800"
      +"startTime": "08:30"
      +"endTime": "10:30"
      +"dateOpeningRegister": "2026-01-13"
      +"dateLimitRegister": "2026-03-17"
      +"showDateOpeningRegister": false
      +"isOpenForRegistration": true
      +"typeStart": "morning"
      +"edition": "40615"
      +"isCurrent": true
      +"registrationType": "paw"
      +"externalRegistrationLink": ""
      +"ticketsNumber": "90"
      +"onlineConfLink": ""
      +"hasWaitingList": false
      +"replay": ""
      +"photos": ""
      +"publication": ""
      +"publication_description": ""
      +"address": {#4578
        +"street": "2 rue de la Chaussée d'Antin"
        +"building": "Bird & Bird"
        +"city": "Paris"
        +"postcode": "75009"
        +"information": ""
        +"gps": "48.8712104,2.3342243"
        +"maps_query": "2+rue+de+la+Chaussée+d'Antin,75009,Paris"
      }
      +"speakerHosts": array:1 [
        0 => "15312"
      ]
      +"speakerGuests": array:3 [
        0 => "16883"
        1 => "1079"
        2 => "16965"
      ]
      +"attendeeReminderLastSent": ""
      +"attendees": array:325 [
        266 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 266
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768313148
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15106 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15106
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768338895
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15309 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15309
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768369937
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        14977 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 14977
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768425758
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2631 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2631
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768470085
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2678 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2678
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768549804
          "date_request" => 1768549804
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10500 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10500
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768560761
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6811 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6811
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768576091
          "date_request" => 1768576091
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        9180 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 9180
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768577131
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10945 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10945
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768589559
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        240 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 240
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768602738
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15451 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15451
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768669118
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1209 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1209
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768765176
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11477 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11477
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768815874
          "date_request" => 1768815874
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        3201 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 3201
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768829228
          "date_request" => 1768829228
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        888 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 888
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768835201
          "date_request" => 1768835201
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10412 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10412
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768860256
          "date_request" => 1768860256
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15292 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15292
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768861021
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        284 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 284
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768908349
          "date_request" => 1768908349
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6706 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6706
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768909844
          "date_request" => 1768909844
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        852 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 852
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768915541
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        3897 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 3897
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768917498
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        3019 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 3019
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768918096
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        3875 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 3875
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768920234
          "date_request" => 1768920234
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        5947 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 5947
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768924676
          "date_request" => 1768924676
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6744 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6744
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768928971
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        854 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 854
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768929760
          "date_request" => 1768929760
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8224 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8224
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768932072
          "date_request" => 1768932072
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6895 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6895
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768988075
          "date_request" => 1768988075
          "expiry_date" => ""
        ]
        15573 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15573
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1768989612
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11074 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11074
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1768993341
          "date_request" => 1768993341
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12238 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12238
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769001257
          "date_request" => 1769001257
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10652 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10652
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769005508
          "date_request" => 1769005508
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15599 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15599
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769014921
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        3994 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 3994
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769055875
          "date_request" => 1769055875
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1374 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1374
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769069028
          "date_request" => 1769069028
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        5174 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 5174
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769074323
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        5089 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 5089
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769075028
          "date_request" => 1769075028
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7446 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7446
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769075052
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1509 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1509
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769075392
          "date_request" => 1769075392
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15379 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15379
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769075578
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10657 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10657
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769076523
          "date_request" => 1769076523
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10614 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10614
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769077108
          "date_request" => 1769077108
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        3915 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 3915
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769078446
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8813 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8813
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769079535
          "date_request" => 1769079535
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15212 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15212
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769079805
          "date_request" => 1769079805
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11577 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11577
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769080149
          "date_request" => 1769080149
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2946 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2946
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769080853
          "date_request" => 1769080853
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1079 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1079
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769081296
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2497 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2497
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769081496
          "date_request" => 1769081496
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8677 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8677
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769082219
          "date_request" => 1769082219
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12215 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12215
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769085113
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15631 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15631
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769085529
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10408 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10408
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769085635
          "date_request" => 1769085635
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15089 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15089
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769085678
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7182 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7182
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769087040
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10075 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10075
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769092356
          "date_request" => 1769092356
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1697 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1697
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769097461
          "date_request" => 1769097461
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11369 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11369
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769098179
          "date_request" => 1769098179
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15176 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15176
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769103152
          "date_request" => 1769103152
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15602 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15602
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769124349
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15229 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15229
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769160643
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15689 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15689
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769164873
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15026 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15026
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769165589
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1579 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1579
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769167898
          "date_request" => 1769167898
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1190 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1190
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769172308
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        14408 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 14408
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769172865
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8570 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8570
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769190130
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8869 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8869
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769195020
          "date_request" => 1769195020
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15013 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15013
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769202647
          "date_request" => 1769202647
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        9654 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 9654
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769267896
          "date_request" => 1769267896
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        492 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 492
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769325703
          "date_request" => 1769325703
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15727 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15727
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769350196
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        4273 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 4273
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769351317
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15713 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15713
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769360590
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        3929 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 3929
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769368266
          "date_request" => 1769368266
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        4457 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 4457
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769374153
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11639 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11639
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769382249
          "date_request" => 1769382249
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        9931 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 9931
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769420841
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        14924 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 14924
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769423113
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        13352 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 13352
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769424176
          "date_request" => 1769424176
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10250 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10250
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769435510
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15098 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15098
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769435729
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15755 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15755
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769440918
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15702 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15702
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769441377
          "date_request" => 1769441377
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15060 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15060
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769445281
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15774 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15774
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769476392
          "date_request" => 1769476392
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10719 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10719
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769510545
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12498 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12498
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769510967
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12447 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12447
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769511270
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        9981 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 9981
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769520272
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15790 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15790
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769522565
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15601 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15601
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769530294
          "date_request" => 1769530294
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15806 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15806
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769549863
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15283 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15283
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769554535
          "date_request" => 1769554535
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10228 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10228
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769572505
          "date_request" => 1769572505
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15812 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15812
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769590466
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6178 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6178
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769595412
          "date_request" => 1769595412
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12360 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12360
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769596899
          "date_request" => 1769596899
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        928 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 928
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769597735
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        9995 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 9995
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769597752
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1339 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1339
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769598043
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7185 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7185
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769601852
          "date_request" => 1769601852
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15821 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15821
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769603538
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12281 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12281
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769605821
          "date_request" => 1769605821
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2644 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2644
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769605852
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12387 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12387
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769610597
          "date_request" => 1769610597
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15830 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15830
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769611056
          "date_request" => 1769611056
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2002 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2002
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769616441
          "date_request" => 1769616441
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1574 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1574
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769616872
          "date_request" => 1769616872
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6098 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6098
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769623115
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15103 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15103
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769629041
          "date_request" => 1769629041
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6828 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6828
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769635316
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        9532 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 9532
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769674677
          "date_request" => 1769674677
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15151 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15151
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769685788
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1018 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1018
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769693703
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15224 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15224
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769711520
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15890 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15890
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769715292
          "date_request" => 1769715292
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15625 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15625
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769716228
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7894 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7894
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769774839
          "date_request" => 1769774839
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        312 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 312
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769776574
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15908 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15908
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769785508
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        702 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 702
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769789114
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15764 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15764
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1769805894
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        573 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 573
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1769946743
          "date_request" => 1769946743
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6852 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6852
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770055649
          "date_request" => 1770055649
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10277 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10277
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770057801
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15322 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15322
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770057990
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15800 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15800
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770078905
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12289 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12289
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770121894
          "date_request" => 1770121894
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6776 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6776
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770125620
          "date_request" => 1770125620
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11490 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11490
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770129489
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        9435 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 9435
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770140320
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1019 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1019
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770207505
          "date_request" => 1770207505
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        712 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 712
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770210499
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11972 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11972
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770210662
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1418 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1418
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770212260
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11675 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11675
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770212349
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12746 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12746
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770212836
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        14003 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 14003
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770216293
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        14009 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 14009
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770216374
          "date_request" => 1770216374
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15037 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15037
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770216377
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16163 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16163
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770217701
          "date_request" => 1770217701
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11427 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11427
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770218080
          "date_request" => 1770218080
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1195 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1195
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770220639
          "date_request" => 1770220639
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10206 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10206
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770224762
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7262 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7262
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770237378
          "date_request" => 1770237378
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11482 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11482
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770268976
          "date_request" => 1770268976
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8047 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8047
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770284745
          "date_request" => 1770284745
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16238 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16238
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770288272
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16243 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16243
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770288765
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8562 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8562
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770294205
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12824 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12824
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770301991
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16272 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16272
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770322339
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16269 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16269
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770324154
          "date_request" => 1770324154
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10009 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10009
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770375322
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16300 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16300
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770379078
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15426 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15426
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770381709
          "date_request" => 1770381709
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16314 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16314
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770400705
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16334 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16334
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770493554
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10329 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10329
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770528573
          "date_request" => 1770528573
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11159 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11159
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770643765
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16381 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16381
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770645710
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        886 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 886
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770646706
          "date_request" => 1770646706
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        488 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 488
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770701411
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16429 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16429
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770722542
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15444 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15444
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770727450
          "date_request" => 1770727450
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15277 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15277
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770734066
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8016 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8016
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770735327
          "date_request" => 1770735327
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8717 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8717
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770735628
          "date_request" => 1770735628
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6081 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6081
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770736512
          "date_request" => 1770736512
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16453 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16453
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770739292
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10214 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10214
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770753333
          "date_request" => 1770753333
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15373 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15373
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770808948
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16105 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16105
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770831287
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2693 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2693
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770844662
          "date_request" => 1770844662
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1260 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1260
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770887914
          "date_request" => 1770887914
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7814 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7814
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770893828
          "date_request" => 1770893828
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6272 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6272
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770894480
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11677 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11677
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770896804
          "date_request" => 1770896804
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16595 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16595
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770902365
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        13339 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 13339
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770904687
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10685 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10685
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1770905039
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6757 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6757
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770920369
          "date_request" => 1770920369
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        375 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 375
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770976273
          "date_request" => 1770976273
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16677 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16677
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1770993883
          "date_request" => 1770993883
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        14858 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 14858
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771006714
          "date_request" => 1771006714
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15640 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15640
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771050334
          "date_request" => 1771050334
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6586 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6586
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771054360
          "date_request" => 1771054360
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16714 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16714
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771080600
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11288 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11288
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771085070
          "date_request" => 1771085070
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        5886 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 5886
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771124415
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16732 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16732
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771187483
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15034 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15034
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771227963
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16298 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16298
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771236035
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15940 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15940
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771240097
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15823 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15823
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771241094
          "date_request" => 1771241094
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        13010 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 13010
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771241554
          "date_request" => 1771241554
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        4704 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 4704
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771242061
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8153 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8153
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771244452
          "date_request" => 1771244452
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8842 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8842
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771261487
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6813 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6813
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771269737
          "date_request" => 1771269737
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16802 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16802
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771280500
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        14017 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 14017
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771314463
          "date_request" => 1771314463
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        13602 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 13602
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771325695
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16547 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16547
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771326597
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16367 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16367
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771328650
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16823 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16823
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771329666
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11960 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11960
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771338728
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16807 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16807
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771347288
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10845 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10845
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771410496
          "date_request" => 1771410496
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2613 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2613
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771420085
          "date_request" => 1771420085
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        4499 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 4499
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771423325
          "date_request" => 1771423325
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16910 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16910
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771425048
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15555 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15555
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771434371
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        2470 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 2470
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771486011
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16987 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16987
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771499726
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        8657 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 8657
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771500130
          "date_request" => 1771500130
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7009 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7009
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771507615
          "date_request" => 1771507615
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1689 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1689
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771513560
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10992 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10992
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771515275
          "date_request" => 1771515275
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        5559 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 5559
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771577840
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17048 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17048
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771581727
          "date_request" => 1771581727
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12276 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12276
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771587911
          "date_request" => 1771587911
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        6199 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 6199
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771780618
          "date_request" => 1771780618
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12823 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12823
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771795703
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15734 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15734
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771833572
          "date_request" => 1771833572
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16787 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16787
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771841044
          "date_request" => 1771841044
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1164 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1164
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771843120
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17159 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17159
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771851884
          "date_request" => 1771851884
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10920 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10920
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771852575
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7701 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7701
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771855665
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        4307 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 4307
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771884321
          "date_request" => 1771884321
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        12429 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 12429
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771941332
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17279 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17279
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771947304
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        4594 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 4594
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1771951253
          "date_request" => 1771951253
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16916 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16916
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771976119
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17131 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17131
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1771978299
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17314 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17314
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1772009473
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17273 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17273
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1772018149
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1997 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1997
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1772025596
          "date_request" => 1772025596
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        16992 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 16992
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1772039489
          "date_request" => 1772039489
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7958 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7958
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1772054333
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        10771 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 10771
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1772102566
          "date_request" => 1772102566
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17180 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17180
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1772105181
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        9851 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 9851
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1772105582
          "date_request" => 1772105582
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        15901 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 15901
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1772113308
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        1723 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 1723
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => "on"
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => 1772116034
          "date_request" => 1772116034
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        11325 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 11325
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1772122436
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17427 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17427
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1772126059
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        17062 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 17062
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "accepted"
          "paw_networking" => ""
          "paw_networking_timestamp" => ""
          "date_request" => 1772184176
          "expiry_date" => null
        ]
        7223 => array:7 [
          "userID" => 7223
          "presence" => "in_person"
          "status" => "declined"
          "paw_networking" => ""
           …3
        ]
        15391 => array:7 [ …7]
        6011 => array:7 [ …7]
        3461 => array:7 [ …7]
        11881 => array:7 [ …7]
        17541 => array:7 [ …7]
        17578 => array:7 [ …7]
        10198 => array:7 [ …7]
        17406 => array:7 [ …7]
        2118 => array:7 [ …7]
        7260 => array:7 [ …7]
        17573 => array:7 [ …7]
        13514 => array:7 [ …7]
        7338 => array:7 [ …7]
        16592 => array:7 [ …7]
        17289 => array:7 [ …7]
        14398 => array:7 [ …7]
        17577 => array:7 [ …7]
        1181 => array:7 [ …7]
        10089 => array:7 [ …7]
        16682 => array:7 [ …7]
        14262 => array:7 [ …7]
        17925 => array:7 [ …7]
        5443 => array:7 [ …7]
        6634 => array:7 [ …7]
        17161 => array:7 [ …7]
        1369 => array:7 [ …7]
        16830 => array:7 [ …7]
        18137 => array:7 [ …7]
        11669 => array:7 [ …7]
        18145 => array:7 [ …7]
        18165 => array:7 [ …7]
        18190 => array:7 [ …7]
        18197 => array:7 [ …7]
        12183 => array:7 [ …7]
        9835 => array:7 [ …7]
        16433 => array:7 [ …7]
        10697 => array:7 [ …7]
        18051 => array:7 [ …7]
        18278 => array:7 [ …7]
        15467 => array:7 [ …7]
        18230 => array:7 [ …7]
        18402 => array:7 [ …7]
        16402 => array:7 [ …7]
        6346 => array:7 [ …7]
        18426 => array:7 [ …7]
        8776 => array:7 [ …7]
        925 => array:7 [ …7]
        9192 => array:7 [ …7]
        17157 => array:7 [ …7]
        1893 => array:7 [ …7]
        18275 => array:7 [ …7]
        18684 => array:7 [ …7]
        18682 => array:7 [ …7]
        1349 => array:7 [ …7]
        12622 => array:7 [ …7]
        11267 => array:7 [ …7]
        1322 => array:7 [ …7]
        15183 => array:7 [ …7]
        11344 => array:7 [ …7]
        16761 => array:7 [ …7]
        694 => array:7 [ …7]
        18838 => array:7 [ …7]
        1423 => array:7 [ …7]
        11394 => array:7 [ …7]
        15328 => array:7 [ …7]
        18981 => array:7 [ …7]
        17670 => array:7 [ …7]
        10970 => array:7 [ …7]
        11861 => array:7 [ …7]
        14203 => array:7 [ …7]
        15356 => array:7 [ …7]
        19105 => array:7 [ …7]
        18678 => array:7 [ …7]
      ]
      +"stats": {#4577
        +"total": "90"
        +"accepted": 79
        +"pending": 20
        +"declined": 226
        +"cancelled": 0
        +"waiting": 0
        +"in_person": 79
        +"online": 0
        +"checked_in": 27
        +"left": 11
      }
    }
  ]
  "__env" => Illuminate\View\Factory {#2419}
  "app" => Illuminate\Container\Container {#2401}
  "override" => "app"
  "display_sidebar" => false
  "notices" => []
  "browser" => null
  "displayArchiveStructs" => false
  "relatedEdition" => WP_Post {#4171}
  "edition_dates" => "23 - 27 March 2026"
  "static_pages" => array:9 [
    "middle_office" => "89"
    "digital_library" => "13219"
    "legal_notice" => "955"
    "privacy_statement" => "12766"
    "contact_us" => "95"
    "sign_in" => "424"
    "visitor_register" => "40592"
    "partner_register" => "28"
    "maintenance" => "40491"
  ]
  "user" => WP_User {#4166}
  "currentEvents" => array:1 [
    0 => 40854
  ]
  "previousEvents" => []
  "__currentLoopData" => array:1 [
    0 => 40854
  ]
  "loop" => null
  "eventID" => 40854
  "event" => WP_Post {#4579}
]